These Homemade Marshmallows are the only marshmallow you’ll ever want from this day forward. Creamy, lofty, and light-as-air, you can customize the flavours any way you’d like.
If you like this homemade marshmallow recipe, you can also make Chocolate Dipped Homemade Kahlua Marshmallows or Mocha Marshmallow Pops.
Unless you’ve been reading Foodie with Family since the beginning, way back in 2008 (hi, Dad!) you might not know that my stepmom, Val, was my partner. We started the blog together and carried on until she became ill. One of the first posts on the blog was for Val’s Homemade Marshmallows.
What makes homemade marshmallows different?
Like most people, I’ve got some weird food dislikes and quirks, and as un-American as it sounds, commercial marshmallows are one of them. Store bought marshmallows have a weird dry outer shell and are pure sugar with nothing redeeming them texturally.
I always thought I disliked marshmallows. These homemade marshmallows, on the other hand, are magical. They are, as Val said, “creamy, lofty, and light-as-air.”
When Val first served me a homemade marshmallow all these years ago, it was a revelation. It wasn’t that I disliked marshmallows, it was that I disliked lousy marshmallows.
These wonderful homemade marshmallows became an instant holiday tradition for us. It’s not officially fall at our house until we have some homemade marshmallows around for peppermint hot chocolate or blender made spiced hot chocolate.
What flavours do I use for a homemade marshmallow recipe?
The sky is the limit! In the pictures, I have Vanilla Nutmeg Marshmallows, but you can most certainly omit the nutmeg for a pure vanilla marshmallow.
Val used to make orange, mint, chocolate, and coffee marshmallows and all were equally delicious. We have done so many versions, I can’t count them all.
The rule of thumb is 1 total tablespoon of extracts. For vanilla nutmeg, I do 2.5 teaspoons of vanilla extract to 0.5 teaspoons of nutmeg extract.
If you forced me to choose a favourite, though, I’d have to say it’s a toss up between these Vanilla Nutmeg ones and orange ones dipped in chocolate. It’s a hard job, but I’d be willing to taste test those any day of the week. Ahem.
I prefer all of my marshmallows to have whatever colour they have naturally from the small amount of extract I add, but sometimes Val played with subtle colours like swirling a couple of drops of yellow and red colouring into her orange marshmallows, or red into her peppermint ones.
Can I use homemade marshmallows in s’mores?
Yes. Most definitely. Please do. You’ll be making the best s’mores you’ve ever had in your entire life if you make them with homemade marshmallows.
In fact, you might never be able to go back if you make them with homemade marshmallows. Ask me how I know.
Do I need special equipment to make homemade marshmallows?
Technically, no. You can get away with making homemade marshmallows if you have an extremely protective oven mitt and a hand mixer, but you almost certainly would like me better if I told you honestly you SHOULD have a stand mixer fitted with a whisk.
The reasoning is sound because basically you’re whipping air into boiling hot candy syrup for some time. In other words, there’s going to be steam.
Holding your hand over that with a hand-mixer is going to become uncomfortable long before the minimum 10 minutes of beating time is done. This is where the stand mixer is worth its weight in gold.
Aside from the stand mixer, all you need is a cake pan, some plastic wrap, and some non-stick cooking spray or neutral oil.
Here is a list of gear you’ll want to have ready before you start the process:
-a stand mixer with whisk attachment
How do I store homemade marshmallows?
This one’s super easy! Toss the cut marshmallows with a little extra powdered sugar. This keeps them from sticking together. Then place them in an airtight container and store at room temperature.
How long will homemade marshmallows keep?
If you don’t give yourself a stomachache by eating them all right away, your marshmallows should keep quite well for up to 3 weeks at room temperature.
Homemade Marshmallows Recipe
-Stir together the sugar, water, and corn syrup in your saucepan only until the sugar is dissolved. Once it reaches that point, don’t stir it again until it has come to a boil and boiled hard for 1 minute.
If you do stir it, you risk crystallizing your sugar which leaves little crunchy bits in your marshmallows. This isn’t the end of the world, but it doesn’t make as smooth an end product.
-Don’t be tempted to double the recipe unless you have a stand mixer much larger than the average. The mixture expands hugely while it is whipped and while it cools.
There is no mess quite like the one you get if you overestimate the potential capacity of your mixer bowl when making marshmallows.
-Remember not to add your extract until the very end of the process. Remember, too, that the rule is to have 1 tablespoon total of extracts.
Even when changing up the flavour from vanilla, I tend to maintain at least 2 teaspoons of vanilla extract to go with 1 teaspoon or less of any other extract.
-Be sure to generously oil your hands before working with the whipped marshmallows unless you really dig feeling sticky.
-Don’t rush them. Marshmallows need to rest to set up. Your patience will be rewarded.
-When it comes time to cut your marshmallows, it’s hard to be too generous when dusting your cutting surface with powdered sugar. These suckers are sticky! Likewise, keep dusting your knife with powdered sugar.
-I find that a long carving knife like this one or a large chef’s knife are the best tools for cutting marshmallows.
If you love these homemade marshmallows, you might also love these other homemade food gifts: pop rocks candy bark, salted pepita brittle, Coffee Jelly, Cranberry Pistachio Christmas Snack Mix, Pumpkin Spice Chai Latte Mix, homemade croissants, pain au chocolat, Chinese spicy chili crisp sauce, and Candied Jalapenos.
Homemade Marshmallows
Ingredients
- .75 oz unflavored gelatin 3 envelopes of Knox gelatin
- 1/2 cup cold water
- 2 cups granulated sugar
- 2/3 cups light corn syrup
- 1/4 cup water
- 1/4 teaspoon salt
- 1 tablespoon pure vanilla extract or combination of other flavor extracts
- Confectioners' sugar
Instructions
- Line 9 x 9-inch or 8 x 8-inch pan with plastic wrap and lightly oil it using your fingers or non-stick cooking spray. Set aside.
- In the bowl of an electric mixer, sprinkle gelatin over 1/2 cup cold water. Soak for about 10 minutes.
- Meanwhile, combine sugar, corn syrup and 1/4 cup water in a small saucepan, whisking only until the sugar is dissolved. Bring the mixture to a rapid boil. As soon as it is boiling, set the timer and allow to boil hard for 1 minute without stirring.
- Carefully pour the boiling syrup into soaked gelatin and turn on the mixer, using the whisk attachment, starting on low and moving up to high speed. Add the salt and beat for between 10 and 12 minutes, or until fluffy and mostly cooled to almost room temperature. After it reaches that stage, add in the extract and beat to incorporate.
- Grease your hands and a rubber or silicone scraper with neutral oil and transfer marshmallow into the prepared pan. Use your greased hands to press the marshmallow into the pan evenly. Take another piece of lightly oiled plastic wrap and press lightly on top of the marshmallow, creating a seal. Let mixture sit for a few hours, or overnight, until cooled and firmly set.
- Sprinkle a cutting surface very generously with confectioner's sugar. Remove marshmallow from pan and lay on top of the sugar. Dust the top generously with sugar as well. Use a large, sharp knife to cut into squares. Separate pieces and toss to coat all surfaces with the sugar.
- Store in an airtight container.
Nutrition
This recipe for Homemade Marshmallows was originally written by my stepmom, Valerie, on December 5, 2008. She passed away several years ago, and I’m updating the post to add some more helpful hints in 2018 but the brief original text written by Val remains below because she was awesome and so are her marshmallows.
Val’s original post
Last year I made homemade marshmallows for the first time. For years I felt too intimidated to make the attempt, not sure why, but I’m so glad I finally gave it a whirl. These need to be started at least a day before you need to serve them or package them for gifts, so be sure to give yourself some leeway. The only change I made to the recipe I found* was to use confectioners sugar alone for the coating, rather than mixing with cornstarch. I don’t like the feel of the cornstarch, and with corn allergies being an issue for some, I felt it was better without.
This recipe is for your basic vanilla flavored marshmallows, but I had success with flavoring in other ways–raspberry flavoring with a touch of red food color, mint flavoring with green, orange flavoring with a touch of yellow and red color together. I also made a spiced marshmallow, adding some ground cinnamon and ground nutmeg to the marshmallow, and also mixing some of the same spice into the confectioners sugar coating. All turned out wonderfully well. Hope you enjoy these as much as we have!
*The recipe Val altered was located on a now-defunct website.
Cindy says
I’d use a large pizza wheel to cute these, I bet it would make it much easier. I’ve been wanting to make homemade marshmallows for years, too. I guess I’ve been a bit intimidated by it also. But you’ve inspired me, I’ll give it a whirl.
Dottie Turrittin says
I do not own a stand mixer, can I use a hand mixer?
Rebecca says
Well, Dottie, you can… but oh my gosh, your shoulder’s gonna hurt if you do. You’ll need to put serious elbow grease behind it for a protracted amount of time.
Beth says
I think the question here was not so much about shoulder strength as it was about the relative outcome of the product. If one does not OWN a stand mixer, then the choice is not about preference, but if the work with a hand mixer is worth the effort it will obviously require. . . . Is the quality of the marshmallow the same?
Rebecca says
Good point, Beth. My knowledge of it working is purely academic and anecdotal. I have not tried to do this manually myself, since I am happily in possession of a stand mixer.
Jessica says
I hope I’m not to late to chime in, but I just made these with a hand mixer and, besides being a little bored while mixing, I had no issues whatsoever with heat or soreness, I just alternated arms frequently. I actually found it easier to clean afterwards than I did with my stand mixer. The point is to whip it like you’re making a much thicker whipped cream, you could possibly use just a hand whisk if you had to but it might cool down too fast for you to get it there in time
Rebecca says
Thanks so much for letting us know the hand mixer worked well for you, Jessica!!!
Danijela says
These look like a dream!
Rebecca says
Thanks so much, Danijela!
Jennifer Kurth says
These are my go to when I want big fat fluffy marshmallows! I absolutely love this recipe &it’s so easy to make . No candy thermometer needed (although I do own one). I’ve made these with Bourbon, Rum, Almond, Orange, Lemon (the last 3 are extracts, the first two were boozy marshmallows)!
The compliments I’ve gotten from giving them as gifts have been amazing. Thanks for the great recipe !
Rebecca says
Hi Jennifer! Thanks so much for taking the time to rate the recipe and tell us about your successes with it! I’m so glad you love them. 🙂
Teresa says
Hello! I was wondering how much of the liquor you used for the bourbon and rum flavored.
Rebecca says
I just replace the vanilla extract with bourbon or spiced rum! 🙂
Gracie says
I made them last night.. and am dipping them in chocolate with my lil one today to deliver to the local PD as a nice treat on this ridiculously cold day. .. A trial run for Christmas gift giving. They turned out great! thanks for the super easy recipe.
K Ann Guinn says
What a fitting tribute to your stepmom. I can’t wait to try these!
Rebecca says
Thanks, K Ann! 🙂
Gary says
Like a sweet walk down memory lane- thank you for sharing this recipe & some lovely memories of Valerie. She was, indeed, a treasure.
Rebecca says
Thanks so much, Gary.
Sue says
I made these years ago and tryed BAKING cocoa,they were so yummy! But I forgot how much to put in ! I think was like 2 tablespoons.any one else ever tyres chocolate? If so how much did you put in.want to make them to take camping. Thanks
Jennifer says
I recently learned how to make marshmallows and now I’m obsessed lol. The recipe I used before finding yours is 1 cup of sugar to one cup of corn syrup and you get it to the softball stage, So because you have two cups of sugar to 2/3 cup of corn syrup it requires less time. I’m just wondering if it actually reaches the softball stage or does it have to do with the amount of sugar? Regardless they taste amazing already. I did the orange flavor and tinted it a very light orange. Thanks for the great recipe, I’ll be making these over and over again!
Stephanie says
I see you never received an answer, I am wondering the same thing. Did you ever make them and determine if 1 minute is enough time?
Rebecca says
All I know is that these marshmallows work perfectly every time without needing to bust out a candy thermometer! I definitely encourage you to try them!
Lisa Terry says
So much easier than other recipes I’ve seen.
Rebecca says
Thank you so much, Lisa!
Sherry says
Amazing! Super easy as well.
Rebecca says
Thanks so much for taking the time to review the recipe, Sherry. I do appreciate it. I’m so glad you love them like we do!!
Hanna says
Can these be frozen to keep?
Rebecca says
Hi Hanna- I am not sure; I have never tried freezing them! I’ll play around with it a little bit in the next couple of weeks.
Pigmom says
I have kids w/ allergies to yellow 5, red 40. After learning so much about artificial dyes we decided to not eat any artificial dyes. It’s not easy it requires us to make or do w/o so many foods. Marshmallows can have a lot of junk in them. I’m going to try ur recipe to make rice crispy squares. I assume after whipping that I can then proceed w/ the recipe and skip setting the marshmallows. I’ll add butter to the pan add the marshmallows when their a little melted add them to the rice crispies. Does this sound ok or do I need to let them set 1st?
Rebecca says
Hey there! I have not tried that, so I’m not sure if something’ll get lost in the not-setting. I imagine it will be okay, but that’s just an educated guess!
Jesi says
How did the rice crispy squares turn out?
Rachael Gildea says
Made these four times and they’re always a hit! I have a food saver and it has definitely prolonged the life of the marshmallows. My daughter uses them in her coffee instead of creamer/sugar and said its absolutely delicious.
Rebecca says
Thanks for the storage tip, Rachael! I’m so glad to know that as sometimes I make *ahem* more marshmallows than we should probably eat in a couple of days. 🙂
Habakkuk says
Really enjoyed this recipe, I used someone’s else’s recipe, but this is the best.
I wanted to add,that I am a Christian, and wanted you to know JESUS CHRIST loves you, he died on the cross for our sins,and all we need is to ask for forgiveness for our sins and to receive JESUS as our SAVIOR,so you can be Assured of a Home in HEAVEN.
Bonnie says
I made these today. They are soooo soft like a pillow. Easy recipe. Thank you.
Rebecca says
That is a perfect way to describe them, Bonnie! I’m so glad you like them! xo
Helen says
Can ypu use rhis recipe for icing cookies?
Amy says
I wanted to help you out posting a pic in testimony but I caint. They were delicious though and I have had a conversion experience😂
Rebecca says
HAHAHA! That is awesome!
Laura says
After all the marshmallows recipes I have read ( about 10+) yours was the best that I read and had the best explanations and easyest directions that were with any of all that I had gone through.
Rebecca says
Ohmygoodness, Laura! Thank you so much for your kind words and for taking the time to rate the recipe. It means a lot to me.
Tobi says
Uh oh! I think I’m getting into the “eat them all and give yourself a stomachache territory”! I had wanted to make marshmallows for literally over a year but was too intimidated, but you made this easy. Found the recipe by way of Preheated Podcast, btw. Thanks so much!
Rebecca says
Ah HAHAHAHHAHA. Thank you, Tobi. I’m so glad you love them and that you found us. 🙂 And thank you for taking the time to rate the recipe. It is much appreciated!
Michelle says
This is such a fun thing to make especially around the holidays. The instructions were very clear and easy to follow. They came out great!
Rebecca says
Thanks so much, Michelle, for letting me know you liked it and for taking the time to rate the recipe. I truly appreciate it!
Katie says
Everything promised & more! So creamy & delicious!!!
Vikki says
Great recipe and great directions that anyone can follow. I would add 1 teaspoon of peppermint next time to make it taste more minty (I only added 1/2 t.).
Deanna Alwahabi says
I have wanted to try to make marshmallows for years but have generally failed at candy making. After reading lots and lots of recipes I tried this one. They came out awesome. Thanks ! I plan to make again with different flavoring. I mixed the powdered sugar with some Hersheys powdered chocolate and the result is life changing lol.
Rebecca says
Wow! Thank you, Deanna! I’m so glad you loved it and it works so well for you!! I also appreciate you taking the time to rate the recipe!
Kate says
Lost my marshmallow recipe.
Found this on Google. I was unsure since it’s much faster and not cooked to 244 degrees.
Fabulous! They’re perfect! Made twice as many in half the time.
Thank you
Rebecca says
Hi Kate! I am so glad you love these. They’re one of my favourite things to make!
And thank you for taking the time to review the recipe, too. It means a lot to me!
Katie Casabella says
Making Modjeskas with this recipe today. Delish!!!
Rebecca says
Happy Marshmallow Making, Katie!!!
Kate Leino says
My goodness these are wonderful. I’ve made homemade marshmallows in the past and sat hovering over the candy thermometer. This recipe is so easy. Local homebrew store carries butterscotch and root beer extract. We’ll also be trying orange, cappuccino, and Irish cream. My kids all say thank you.
Rebecca says
Oooooh! I love the idea of root beer and butterscotch marshmallows! I’m so glad you love them, Kate!! xoxo
wendy barney says
These are amazing!!!!
Kimberly McFall says
These are dreamy! I also made a second batch adding 1/4 sifted dark cocoa powder — also lovely (like a bite of hot chocolate!). I like smaller marshmallows, so I used a cookie sheet and spread them thin so I could get “mini mallows”. I would also encourage people to be serious about using a well oiled spatula— even the handle— if you are scraping seeping in the mixing bowl (trust me on this one *ha*). #sticky
Thank you so much for this amazing recipe — it is my favorite version. The legacy of your Val lives on through this beautiful bite.
Rebecca says
You just made my day, Kimberly! Thank you so much for your kind words and for rating the recipe. I truly appreciate it.
hfrom says
So easy and delicious! Thanks for sharing your step mother’s amazing recipe!😊
Rebecca says
You’re so very welcome, hfrom! I’m so glad you love it. Thanks for taking the time to rate it!
Rosemary says
I’ve never commented on a recipe before, but I had to for this one. I just finished cutting these up and tested one. The first thing I could think of was “Oh my gosh, these are real marshmallows!”. I just used a tablespoon of vanilla, and plan to dip the bottom half in chocolate then graham cracker crumbs. Thank you for such an easy and complete recipe.
Rebecca says
Well THAT just made my day! Thank you, Rosemary!
Pigmom says
that sounds so good and easy. I think I have to make marshmallows so I too can dip them in chocolate and graham crackers
Cory says
Thank you for the lovely recipe and story. I’m using a piping bag to extrude my marshmallows then cutting them into minis. These are for my “hot chocolate bombs” … spheres of dark chocolate filled with mini marshmallows. I put them in a mug and pour sweetened hot milk over top. It’s absolutely decadent and a gorgeous display!
Verena Lisinski says
I am in the process of making them. I found that I had a lot of marshmallow for an 8 x 8 pan, so I might use a 9 x 9 next time. They are currently “resting”.
I had a question about dissolving the sugar; is that while you are heating it or try to dissolve before heating? Should it be over High temp until it dissolves and then boils?
Also, have you tried a vegan gelatin? I had Knox in the house, but my daughter is vegan, so I wondered if the results would be the same.
As mentioned, these are super easy to make and a stand-mixer is a must!!!
Rebecca says
Thanks so much taking the time to rate the recipe, Verena! I have not tried vegan gelatin before, so I’m afraid I don’t have advice on that. If you try it, please let me know how it works out. As for the sugar, I whisk it a bit before it hits the heat, but then use medium high heat.
BJ says
Great recipe! So easy and taste great ..
Rebecca says
I’m so glad you liked it, BJ. Thanks for taking the time to rate the recipe!
Ceara says
I have a question for you. Have you ever tried using this recipe to make a marshmallow cake? My son requested one for his birthday and I have been looking at bunch of recipes to find one. I was wondering if these marshmallow would be firm enough to hold its form.
Rebecca says
I think that’ll work great, Ceara! It really is pretty firm set after you let it rest overnight. 🙂 I have to add the disclaimer that I haven’t actually tried that myself, though!
Ceara Therrien says
Thank you
Pigmom says
That was easy. Made a batch for rice crispy squares and a 2and batch for marshmallows. Planned to dip in chocolate and graham cracker crumbs but their getting eaten to fast. I was concerned w/ not having an actual temp the boil a min. doesn’t always work for me. Like what if I start timing to early or to late then I have issues being at 4700’ it sometimes affects cooking. My other concern was powder sugar mess like w/ donuts. I had absolutely nothing to worry about used the exact recipe w/ the exception of plastic wrap I used parchment paper. I had to use 8×8 pan because 9×9 had homemade butter toffee. Everything turned out perfect. I would do 2 things different I would use the 9×9 pan and I will try to cut more uniform. Tomorrow I plan to try and make this recipe using Swerve as the sugar if it’s successful I will have lite marshmallows. It should cut the sugar by at least half. I can’t believe how easy and fast this recipe is. Thanks
Jennifer Hill says
How did it go with the Swerve? The suspense is killing me!
Rebecca says
HA! It’s killing us all!
Angela says
I was wondering about altitude as well, I’m at 7000’. Worried that it won’t be set up, I guess just try it and see what happens.
Rebecca says
Oooh, please check back in and let us know if it sets up for you, Angela! I don’t know anyone else at that altitude, so that seems like a good piece of information to have for the future!
Cheryl says
I loved the vanilla marshmallows made from your recipe.I used a candy thermometer.If I understand the recipe correctly, if I want to make peppermint marshmallows, I would use 2.5 t of vanilla and .5 t of peppermint extract.If I add a little red color to make them pink, do I need to make adjustments to the recipe for that.Thank you.
Rebecca says
Hi Cheryl! If you want to add a little red colour, just add it in at the very end when you add the extracts!
Cheryl J Naegler says
thank you -do you have any suggestions for how to vary for coffee marshmallows or maple flavored marshmallows (with maple syrup?).Thx. CherylChery
Kellie says
Easy recipe and instructions. Very pleased with the turnout, thank you!
Rebecca says
Thanks so much, Kellie! I’m so glad you like them!
Jesi says
If you make spiced marshmallows (nutmeg or cinnamon), do you use 2 teaspoons of vanilla and 1 teaspoon total of spices?
Rebecca says
Hi Jesi- You will just need to experiment a bit with it. Start with lower amounts and add more in to the powdered sugar before cutting it if you find it is too mild.
Angela says
Do you use a liquid nutmeg and cinnamon extract, or the ground?
Rebecca says
Hi Angela! I had a liquid nutmeg extract, but if that’s not available, you could whisk a little ground nutmeg into your powdered sugar, I imagine!
Yvonne Feld says
Made these this weekend & they turned out perfectly! Thanks for such a wonderful recipe!
Rebecca says
I’m so glad you loved them, Yvonne!!
Mark James says
Yummy!
Rebecca says
Thanks so much, Mark!
Daniette says
This was the simplest recipe and it turned out exactly right.
Normally I follow a recipe and then tweak it in future if I keep it, but this needs no alterations. The only quibble I have is w the vagueness for how long to stir the cooked sugar mix (for me, took about 2 -3 min before mixture was smooth looking and I use organic sugar from Costco and it’s not as fine ).
I have a stand mixer, so it did all of the work while I read an article on my phone standing by.
Absolutely true, do not double. I have a six quart kitchenaid and there was no room for a double batch by the time it started puffing up from beating in the air.
I used a 8×8” pan bc I didn’t have a 9×9 and it filled to the rim with marshmallow so I think next time I’ll use a bigger pan.
So incredible pleased how easily this came together. Thanks for sharing!
Rebecca says
Thanks so much, Daniette. I am so glad you loved it and I appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback and rate the recipe!
marjorie mckeown says
I always wanted to make marshmallows but for some reason they always seemed so complicated to make. I made these at Christmas time and they were a hit!!! Not only yummy but beautiful too. Next time I want to try to cut them out with a cookie cutter for different shapes (just for fun) and maybe drizzle some chocolate across them. This recipe is easy to follow and I will make these again. So glad I found foodiewithfamily…she makes me look like I’m a good cook.
Rebecca says
Awww, Marjorie! I really appreciate you taking the time to review the recipe and let me know you love it. 🙂 I’ve taken them and put them on popsicle sticks then coated them in chocolate, too. 🙂
Nancy says
I don’t have a whisk attachment for my stand alone mixer. Will the blades do the job?
Rebecca says
Hi Nancy- I’m afraid I’ve never tried it with the paddle. I have some doubts about whether it would work, but the good news (if you decide to go for it) is that you’ll at least get marshmallow creme out of it. 🙂
Katie says
Turned out terrible tasting, tasted like straight up gelatin.
Rebecca says
Something definitely went wrong for you then, Katie. Would you like for me to try to help figure out where it went off?
Bryan says
I made a batch and they were good, but still had a gelatin taste to them. Is that supposed to happen or did something to wrong with my batch?
Rebecca says
Hi Bryan- They should not taste of gelatin. I’m wondering if something went a little wrong for you. Did you soak the gelatin as instructed ahead of time? And did you add the extract(s) at the end of the whipping time?
Elizabeth says
I LOVED these! So easy. One question, though. I have little clumps of gelatin in some. I noticed when I started mixing it that there were some lumps, but I didn’t know what to do. How do you make sure there are no lumps of gelatin before you begin mixing? Do I take them out? Stir the gelatin/water?
Rebecca says
Hi Elizabeth! I’d say two good tricks to prevent gelatin lumps are a) to make sure your gelatin is free-flowing and lump free before adding to the water, and b) to sprinkle it evenly over the surface of the water when you’re adding it to the water. That should definitely help you! 🙂 Let me know if that works for you on your next batch.
Nicole L says
Can these be frozen for use a few months down the road?
Rebecca says
Hi Nicole- I have never frozen them because my guys eat them all 🙂 I’ve read that it can be done, but I cannot speak to that from personal experience. Please let me know how it works if you try it.
Natalie says
Yummmm
Monica says
These are incredible!!! I made them as Christmas gifts for my coworkers and they raved about them! None had ever had a homemade marshmallow before and were so surprised at how tasty they are. I made them again today for hot cocoa since my husband has asking for another batch for awhile haha. The recipe is great and directions are very well explained and easy to follow. Thanks so much for sharing!!!!!
Rebecca says
Oh, Monica, thank you for taking the time to rate the recipe and tell you why you loved it. It made my day!!!
Lorelei Rogers says
Absolutely delicious and sooooo easy!! Thank you for your moms recipe!!
Rebecca says
You’re VERY welcome!! I’m so glad you loved it!
Jennifer LaScala says
I just finished making these and they were super easy with no mess at all! I followed the directions exactly! Great recipe! My family and I will be making our marshmallows from.now on! Thanks!
Rebecca says
Thank you, Jennifer! I’m so glad you loved both the process and the marshmallows! Thank you for taking the time to let me know and also for rating the recipe!
Robin says
Made these today and they are DREAMY. A couple of questions: 1. There are some little hard bits in there that feel like gelatin (but maybe sugar?) Am I supposed to mix the gelatin with the water after sprinkling it on top in the bowl? 2. They are a little creamy (as opposed to fluffy.) I only had time to let them set 3 hours (we are making s’mores!) Will they set more as they sit overnight or once we cut, the setting is over?
Thank you!!
Rebecca says
Hey Robin- You definitely want to let them sit overnight for optimal texture. The little hard bits in there could indicate that you were stirring the sugar/water/corn syrup mixture after it was already boiling. That sometimes forms crystals. The other thing you’d want to watch for is to make sure you sprinkle the gelatin over the surface of the water vs pouring it all in in one spot. I’m so glad you love them, though, I mean they’re delicious even with the little crunchy bits in there!!!
Brittany says
This recipe hits the bull’s-eye!
Perfection.
Rebecca says
I’m so glad you loved it, Brittany!
Amy White says
These marshmallows taste incredible! Thank you for this wonderful recipe. It was quick and easy, and I will be making them repeatedly, if my husband and kids have anything to say about it!
Rebecca says
Thank you, Amy! I’m so glad you took the time to let me know and rate the recipe!
Hatice says
Hi I’m really confused about the gelatine
I have the leaf ones each one is 3 g
How much do I use in this Recepie
Rebecca says
Hi Hatice- I don’t use leaf gelatine, but a quick google search yielded this information: “You can successfully substitute sheet gelatin for powdered gelatin in any recipe by using the following scaling. 1 (0.25 oz.) envelope granulated gelatin = 1 tablespoon powdered gelatin = 3 sheets leaf gelatin.” I hope this helps!
Hailey Stanley says
That was so helpful I wanted to cry!!! It worked very well and we all enjoyed then. Thank You
Rebecca says
Aw bless, Hailey! Thanks so much. I appreciate you taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you loved it!
Morgan says
Can I use dark corn syrup? Its what I have in the house right now and I dont know if it will affect it weird
Rebecca says
Hi Morgan- I don’t think I’d be inclined to use dark corn syrup for these. I know some folks have used honey to good effect, though!
Lynda says
Sounds amazing, I m going to give them a try and report back 👍
Rebecca says
I hope you love them as much as we do, Lynda!xoxo
Helena Gamble says
Hello,
Thank you for this wonderful recipe. I plan on making this because my daughter likes Rice Crispy treats but I don’t have store bought marshmallows. Do you think I can use the base of this recipe in a Rice Crispy treats recipe? Typically the marshmallow is melted with butter. For example after mixing the gelatin and the sugar syrup, can I just add the butter to the portion I will use in my Rice Crispy treat recipe, without forming the actual marshmallow, and then melting marshmallow again?
Your input is greatly appreciated.
Rebecca says
Hi Helena- Thanks so much for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you love it. I am pretty confident that these would work in rice crispy treats, although I have not personally tried that. Please let me know how it pans out for you if you try it!
Emily G says
Made these and they were fabulous…and really easy thanks to your wonderful recipe! I added a little cocoa powder to the powdered sugar for the final coating— heavenly! Am already thinking these would make great Christmas gifts!
Rebecca says
I agree, Emily! I’m so glad you love these!
Jenn says
So good and everyone LOVED them! :). I’m never going back to store bought!
Rebecca says
I’m so glad you love them, Jenn! I feel the same way. I can’t even handle store bought any more! Thank you for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know.
Denise says
I made these this morning – following the recipe exactly as written. They are the softest, fluffiest marshmallows I’ve ever eaten. I look forward to toasting them, for 4th of July. They’re amazing! Thanks for the recipe (and the memories that will now be associated with homemade marshmallows)!
Rebecca says
That is so wonderful, Denise! Thank you so very much for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me (and everyone else!) know how much you love them. xoxoxo
Mia says
Was wondering if you can divide the mixture up to make different flavors. I see recipe makes 36 so was wondering if I could make like 12 vanilla ones, 12 of a different flavor and maybe 12 of another flavor? Hope that question makes sense!
Rebecca says
That makes perfect sense, Mia! I have to say I’d be included to make 3 different batches because wrestling with a bowl full of sticky marshmallow to divide it sounds very not fun to me. 🙂 HAHAHAHA. Theoretically, you could definitely do that, though.
Shali says
Hi, we can’t get corn syrup in the uk. Do you know of glucose syrup or anything else can replace it in this? X
Rebecca says
You betcha! Lyle’s Golden Syrup should work quite well!
Maureen says
Since it says not to double, would it work to use a larger pan and have thinner marshmallows? We have a big group with lots of kids going camping coming up soon!
Rebecca says
Hi Maureen- You could definitely do that! Or just make back to back batches. I’ve done that quite a few times!
Elizabeth says
These are AMAZING. I wanted to make some without corn syrup (a friend’s son is allergic to corn). Can I substitute the corn syrup for maple syrup and everything else stay the same?
Rebecca says
I’ve not personally tried it with maple syrup, but Lyle’s Golden Syrup and honey have both worked well for me. 🙂
Jillian says
I just made these and they are setting up now. I oiled my plastic wrap and hands with coconut oil and oh my it was so yummy of a teeny bit of flavor to the marshmallows. The marshmallow fluff before setting up is divine. My 2 year old loves it. He loves marshmallows so much I wanted to find a way to make them without all the extra junk in the store bought ones. I can’t wait to see how they set up. Not sure if they are supposed to set up in the fridge or not? My house is hot so I put them in the fridge so I guess I’ll see!
Rebecca says
Thanks so much for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you love it, Jillian! I truly appreciate it!
Shannon Bryan says
I made these for my husband in a lemon flavor, he loved them! Still has some and just snacks on them. I no longer have my stand mixer, but when I get one again, I want to try to make some with espresso powder. Thank you for the recipe! It was rather simple to make.
Rebecca says
Hi Shannon! I’m so glad you love them!! They are great with espresso powder! (They’re also nice when dusted with espresso powder/confectioner’s sugar. 🙂 )
Katrina says
I never made marshmallows because I assumed it was a difficult process. At least with this recipe, that is not true! These were easy to make and the instructions are well written. My family loves them much more than store bought. The longer you leave them in storage the more like a store bought marshmallow in firmness and texture they become. If you are going to toast these for smores, run them over the flame quickly to caramelize the outside. If you hover too long they will completely melt away!
Rebecca says
Thank you so much for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you love it, Katrina! You’re spot on with the toasting advice. They’re likely to run away from you if you try to get them super dark!
Rebecca Jackson says
Thank you so much for this wonderful recipe, and I love how you are carrying on the work that you and Val started together 🙂 I have been eyeing this recipe for several weeks and just decided to give it a whirl last night. To my delight, I awoke to perfect homemade marshmallows on the first cool day we have had in Georgia in a while. I can hardly wait to dig out my hot chocolate ingredients and place these beauties on top. I am already planning to gift some to my neighbors and make another batch. The possibilities are endless! Do you have any advice for using honey? I am thinking of making chocolate ones next, but my Covid kitchen is low on corn syrup. Thanks again for sharing!
Rebecca says
Thank you so much, Rebecca! I’m so glad you loved it and thank you for taking the time to rate the recipe. You can definitely use honey or golden syrup. I’ve also heard that some folks have used maple syrup, but I don’t have any personal experience with that. I find the honey ones tasty and a little softer.
Jennifer Leamons says
Am trying to come up with “Outside Box Marshmallow” Flavors for a cooking demo I have been asked to do. A friend mentioned a Sweet Potato & Bacon S’more and we were trying to wrap our heads around how to make a sweet potato flavored marshmallow? Do you think juicing a sweet potato and adding the juice to your above recipe would work? Demo is in 2 1/2 weeks, help!?
Thank you from North Carolina! 🙂
Rebecca says
Hi Jennifer! I’m not sure adding sweet potato juice would work. Have you seen sweet potato powder you can buy? You might be able to sift that with some confectioner’s sugar to dust the outside! I’m thinking you might have better luck with using the sweet potato as a component for the graham cracker, though. Maybe do a bourbon marshmallow 🙂
Stacey Neufeld says
Oh. My. Goodness. So easy and so incredible. Cut very nicely with a large chef knife. Although now bagged marshmallows taste awful- Still no regrets lol. Thank you so much for sharing!!
Rebecca says
Thank you so much for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you love it, Stacey! I’m with you! I can’t eat the bagged marshmallows any more!
Valerie says
Another idea for marshmallow pan is mini cupcake pan. I’m going to try that will let you know how that works. I’m not much for marshmallow but you make these sound good and I like trying new things, and yes my name is Valerie 🙂
Rebecca says
Hi Valerie- You have a wonderful name.
Terry Weakes says
I can’t wait to “try” to make my own, but I’m certain they won’t come close to Val’s! Thank you for sharing her story as well as the receipe!
Rebecca says
I’m betting yours will be delicious, Terry.
Angel says
This recipe looks delightful! I was wondering if these treats were good to ship? I’m in Texas and my little brother is stuck in Minnesota for the holidays due to the pandemic. It is fall and going into winter soon, so i don’t think the temperatures would be too hard on them, in transit. Do you think these marshmallows would survive the journey? And if so do you have any tips for shipping homemade candy like this?
Rebecca says
Hi Angel- That’s such a sweet idea (literally and figuratively). I think it’ll be a-okay if you ship them. I’d make sure they went priority mail and also were well dusted with confectioner’s sugar before being packaged possibly individually. I’m a big fan of overkill in packing while shipping. 🙂
Tash D says
This recipe is honestly amazing! Easy instruction, perfect texture, and delicious! I’ve already shared it with several people!!!
Rebecca says
Thank you, Tash! I really appreciate you taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you love it! They’re so good, aren’t they?
Kathy L Garner says
Can you please tell me how you made your marshmallows chocolate.
Rebecca says
Hi Kathy- I’m not quite sure what you’re asking… These marshmallows are vanilla. Do you mean my hot chocolate on a stick? Or my chocolate dipped Kahlua marshmallows?
Ali says
Approximately how long does this recipe take to make? And approx how long should the marshmallow be left to cool in fridge?
Rebecca says
Hi Ali- I let them cool at room temp overnight before cutting. 🙂 And I haven’t timed it exactly, but they should take under 30 minutes to make.
Lavern says
I’m wanting to make rice krispie squares. Can I use the “pre” set mixture with the rice krispies, or do I need to let them set and then melt them?
Rebecca says
Hi Lavern- I’m sorry to say I can’t be of much help because I haven’t made rice krispie square with this. Since the marshmallows are usually melted with butter, I’m guessing you’d need to add some butter to the hot mixture after it’s been whipped… but again, that’s just a guess!
Lorraine says
I finally decided to make marshmallows today after thinking about it for years. This recipe rocks. I wasn’t careful in my sprinkling of the gelatin and ended up with some not mixed in the water at all. I wasn’t careful in my timing of the boiling mixture ( but within 10 seconds). It came out perfectly! I finished it by noon, it was ready for our hot chocolate by 6. These came out so well, why did I ever buy them?!
Rebecca says
I’m so glad you love them, Lorraine! Thank you for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you love it!
Jennifer says
To prevent gelatin bits can you melt the gelatin?? Would thar ruin the recipe?? I tried sprinkling over the water and still got bits
Rebecca says
If you sprinkle it evenly over the water and let it sit it should take care of the bits. 🙂
Emma says
I just finished making this recipe and they are in the fridge to set/cool down. I’m so excited to try them! I did a little taste test as I was emptying out my mixer bowl and it was delicious. The recommendation of an 8×8 or 9×9 baking pan is a great idea if like me you really like wider marshmallows. Tip: If you can’t find unflavored corn syrup, use half the amount of vanilla.
Rebecca says
Thanks so much for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you’re having great success with it, Emma! And great tip about the unflavoured corn syrup. 🙂
Regina Goodine says
I am making these again today….. I think this makes batch 7 or 8 EVERYONE loves them!!!! I mailed plain and peppermint to my Mom in New England and she was in Heaven. I’m also sending them as a surprise to friends to open and enjoy during our Holiday Zoom Call. Tell your Dad that Val is bring much needed Joy to us this Holiday Season. Thank you, Regina
Rebecca says
Oh Regina. Thank you so much for taking the time to rate the recipe AND for taking the time to be so kind in your comment. You really did make my day and I’ll be sure to pass the message along to my Dad.
Jodi Ventimiglia says
Hello! Can you use a silicone mold for these?
Thank you!!!
Rebecca says
Hi Jodi- I think that theoretically that should work! I also think that dividing that much sticky marshmallow fluff into individual molds might put me off of trying it, but yes- it oughta work! 🙂 I’m just lazy.
A.G. says
Unbelievable! Followed the instructions to a T and they were absolute perfection and INSANELY EASY. I’m a seasoned cook and baker…have always wanted to try making my own marshmallows but was scared off by the candy-making approach of it. Finally bought a candy thermometer and I didn’t even need it! Filling up mason jars with mini marshmallows that I’ve chopped small (about a half inch big) to give as Christmas gifts to friends and neighbours. THANK YOU! These are glorious… May your step-mom’s memory be eternal.
Rebecca says
Rhonda- Thank you SO much for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you loved it (and how easy it was!) I’m so glad you found me and I love the mini marshmallow idea, too!!
Dana says
I, too was intimidated to try to make these but am so happy I did♥️ Thank you for sharing g your step moms recipe as it continues to spread her wonderfully delicious creation in to other families 🤶🏻
Rebecca says
Thank you so much, Dana, for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you love it and have had success with it!! I’m so glad you are loving Val’s recipe as much as I do!
Shelley says
I tried these on the weekend and they turned out amazing!! We followed some of the recommended change-ups, like omitting the corn starch and adding cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove to the icing sugar. Beyond delicious!! Now we’re planning to make these for Christmas gifts.
Thank you for sharing the delicious and easy to follow recipe!
Rebecca says
You’re so very welcome, Shelley! Thank you for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you love it!
Patty says
I made your marshmallows recipe today for the first time ever, they were so easy and delicious. I do have. Bosch mixer but chose to use my hand mixer, which has a wire whip and a high speed of 16. It worked like a champ, thank you for your easy to follow directions and recipe. I’m looking forward to sharing them with my grandkids, I know they’re going to love them.
Rebecca says
You’re so welcome, Patty! I’m so glad you loved the recipe AND took the time to rate it and let me know you loved it! Merry Christmas!
Cindy says
This worked well for me. Thank you for sharing. It’s so much easier and better than watching a candy thermometer. Yesterday I did that with another recipe and overcooked the syrup because my thermometer was off. The result was dense, chewy marshmallow not fluffy. I just finished your recipe and I’ll be waiting several hours to cut them. Can’t wait, they look fluffalicious!!! 😁
Rebecca says
Thanks so much, Cindy!!! You’re going to love these!! I can’t wait for you to come back and rate the recipe!
Cindy says
These are easy to make and the results are amazing and tasty! Thank you for a perfect recipe! This is a keeper and I want to experiment with flavors and colors. I tried to post a picture but couldn’t. 😋👍🏻
Rebecca says
Thanks so much, Cindy!!! Please join our facebook group and post a pic! I’d love for you to be able to show off! 🙂
Bryan says
These came out perfectly on the first try and were crazy easy to make! I added toasted coconut to the top and they’re so good!! I’m already planning on making several more batches and gonna play with sprinkles and different extracts for some holiday food gifts.
Rebecca says
Thank you, Bryan!!! Thanks for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you love it. They’re so good for customizing, too!
Jaime says
These were a cinch to make and even though I added the salt at the wrong time and forgot the nutmeg (duh!) they turned out amazing!
I used a foil disposable pan lined with Saran wrap and used my hands with coconut oil on them to grease it. I was worried about sticking, but they flipped out nicely when set, and the wrap came right off before I sliced them.
I highly recommend this recipe! They are so light and airy and rich you may never go back to store
Bought again! 100% approval by all 5 of my taste testers. We can’t wait to try the peppermint hot cocoa recipe from this site with these tomorrow for Christmas Eve!
Rebecca says
I’m so glad, Jaime! Thanks so much for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you love it!!! Great tips!
Paige Scott says
Worked amazing and I found the explanation in the beginning very helpful. I cook a lot but almost never read the article before the recipe but I’m glad I did.
One thing that should be noted is that before you add your extracts, gelatin smells like wet dog. Upon some research I found this is normal but it did scare me. I also added fresh ground nutmeg and it was amazing and added nice little specs to the marshmallows. Thank you for the recipe!!
Rebecca says
HA! You’re so right, Paige. Gelatin smells a bit like dog feet but it all works out. Thank you for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you love it.
Beth Grenier says
Can’t wait to make this
Rebecca says
I think you’ll love it, Beth! 🙂
Liz says
Followed recipe exactly but nothing changed in the mixing bowl after 12 minutes on high. 😭
Rebecca says
Hi Liz- I’m sorry to hear you’re having difficulties, but there has to be something we missed along the way… This recipe is bulletproof!
Let’s see if we can figure out what the issue was. Is it possible you measured incorrectly or omitted/changed an ingredient? What brand of gelatin did you use? And what type of corn syrup did you use?
Did you scatter the gelatin powder over the cold water in the mixer bowl and let it sit for a full 10 minutes? And did you bring the sugar/corn syrup/1/4 cup of water to a hard boil and let it boil for 1 minute exactly?
After that, did you pour it over the gelatin/water mixture and start your mixer on low slowly raising it to high and THEN add the salt? Did you remember not to add the extract until the end of the mixing time?
If yes to all of that, what type of mixer are you using?
Cindy says
I made the marshmallows and they are spectacular! I just don’t understand how it works boiling the sugar for only one minute. But it does. Other recipes say to boil the sugar until it reaches 240°.
I was wondering if I could add cocoa powder or something to make these into chocolate marshmallows?
Thank you for a wonderful recipe!
Cindy
Rebecca says
Thanks so much, Cindy!!! I’m so glad you love these. And I’m not sure how this works so easily when so many other recipes are convoluted, but it does and I’m awfully happy it does. I’ve not tried adding cocoa powder IN the marshmallows, but I’ve done a mix of cocoa powder and powdered sugar on the outside and loved them!
Tawney says
I’m waiting for mine to set, but I added Piña Colada flavouring to a single batch and I’m planning to dust them with powdered sugar mixed with shredded coconut!
I also made a double batch of Vanilla (mostly because I only had a 9×13 baking dish left) and I’m very excited! I’m setting them by an open window to set quicker. Thanks for the great recipe! 🤗
Rebecca says
Well now THAT sounds AMAZING, Tawney!!!!
Ilene says
Absolutely delicious. I’ve made at least 10 batches with this recipe and they are perfect every time. I do use two 8×8 pans. I have made vanilla, chocolate, orange, cherry, lemon, chocolate mint. I’m addicted. Thanks for sharing the recipe.
Rebecca says
You’re so welcome, Ilene! Thank you for taking the time to let me know you love it!
Catherine says
Would it be possible to reduce the amount of sugar by half a cup/full cup?
Rebecca says
Hi Catherine- I would not be willing to do that myself because we are making candy here… If you do give it a try, please let me know how it works out for you.
Maggie says
I was thinking of making these in heart shapes for Valentin’s day and would like to dip some in Chocolate. I was wondering if I should leave the powdered sugar off if dipping in chocolate.
Rebecca says
Hi Maggie! What I’d do is still dust in powdered sugar to cut them, then carefully brush them off as much as you can. 🙂
Rebecca says
Also, check out what I did here: Mocha Marshmallow Pops
Cindy says
Love, love, love these! Made them 3 times! Once with Christmas sprinkles, once through in 1/3 cup chopped chocolate and i’m getting ready to use a heart cookie cutter on my strawberry flavored valentine marshmallows. THANK YOU! ❤️
Cindy
Rebecca says
You’re so welcome, Cindy! And thank YOU for taking the time to let me know you love them!
Jamila says
Hi there, I thought ill share my review for this AMAIZING marshmallow recipe. Hands down the best ever!
Only if I could post my marshmallows pic they were Perfect!
However I had a question is there a way to reduce the sugar? Would decreasing the quantity of sugar by a whole cup make effect the recipe in anyway?
Please do write back soon so I can attempt again very soon.
Much love
Jamila.
Rebecca says
You’re the sweetest, Jamila! Thank you so much for taking the time to review the recipe and let me know you love it!! I’d love it if you’d join our facebook community and post a picture of your gorgeous marshmallows!! I’m afraid I’ve never tried reducing the sugar, but my instinct is that it wouldn’t work out too well. The sugar forms the candy which is what makes the structure of the marshmallow. I think there might be other recipes that make their way around lower sugar quantities, but I’m betting you’ll need to make use of a candy thermometer to make sure you’re hitting the right stage!
Chelsy says
Thank you for sharing this wonderful recipe. I found this recipe some time ago, but finally made them tonight. My mother-in-law has been talking about these homemade marshmallows she bought at a farmer’s market in British Columbia a few years ago, and I wanted to make some to surprise her. I hope she likes them!
Rebecca says
That is awesome, Chelsy! Thank you so much for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you love it!
Aubrey says
Can you use liquids other than water? Like coffee?
Rebecca says
Hi Aubrey- I haven’t tested that with coffee, but it seems like it ought to work. 🙂 Please let me know if you give a go how it works out for you. I’d be more inclined to just use coffee extract, though. 🙂
Yo says
they were difficult and i threw them off a cliff.
Rebecca says
Ummmm, okay? What was difficult?
Lee says
Thank you!
Rebecca says
You’re very welcome!
Jane E Borodkin says
I live in Tucson; it getting warm enough to sit around the fire pit and make smores (Mid -March)
I started looking for marshmallows in the stores, but none can be found.
I am excited to try this recipe.
The orange-flavored ones sound divine to me; could I use orange zest?
Then dip one half with chocolate.
Rebecca says
Hi Jane! Well THAT sounds DELICIOUS! 🙂 You could use orange zest at the end with extract. I’d use orange extract, too, to up the flavour if it were me making them. 🙂
Dawn Stuczynski says
Initially I was intimidated by the thought of making my own marshmallows. This recipe was so easy and delicious! Made these for Easter and dipped them in chocolate. I can’t wait to put them out.
Rebecca says
Thanks so much for taking the time to rate the recipe and let us know you love it, Dawn!
Suze Bain says
Just made these for the first time. Recipe is spot on, they were so easy to make. Dipped some of them in chocolate and toasted coconut. Absolutely scrumptious!
Rebecca says
Thanks so much for taking the time to rate the recipe and let me know you loved the marshmallows, Suze!!