Today, I am a mind reader.
I am going to predict the reaction of all readers outside the Western New York region (or those who have never lived or visited here.) “Wow. Boiled potatoes with butter. Big deal.”
I must tell you gently that you’re wrong. Wrongity wrong wrong WRONG wrong.
These are no mere boiled potatoes. These are salt potatoes.
Look closely at the photo. Do you see that white dusty appearance to the potatoes?
That is a super fine coating of salt left from boiling in heavily salted water, draining and air drying. Are you ready for another telepathic demonstration?
Many of you are now saying, “Oookay. Boiled potatoes in salty water. Whoopee.” Have a little faith, folks!
I only share my favorite recipes with you. This is definitely one of them.
Salt potatoes are a fixture on the Upstate New York and Western New York summer barbecue/picnic/county fair/carnival circuit. Where there is a grill fired up, there is likely to be a pot of water on the boil for a big bowl of buttered salt potatoes.
Around these parts, salt potatoes represent summer as much or more than potato salad. They ARE summer.
They are so popular, that they’re sold as “kits” (the kits are nothing more than perfect sized potatoes and a packet of salt) in even the smallest grocery stores. It was one the first things my husband requested for his Father’s Day cookout and I guarantee you these will be on the Fourth of July menu for three-quarters of the households in our region.
So, what’s the difference between a mere boiled potato and a salt potato? A boiled potato is dropped into plain or lightly salted water, boiled until tender and served, usually, with butter and chopped herbs.
Salt potatoes, on the other hand, use a formula to determine how salty the water should be. Generally speaking, bring to a boil three quarts of water, stir in three-quarters of a pound of good old-fashioned table salt, then carefully lower in four and a quarter pounds of Size B new white boiling potatoes.
When they’re tender, drain in a colander and let air dry a bit to form that signature white dusting of salt. Top with butter and serve hot, warm, cold or anywhere in between. Then die of happiness when you take your first bite.
It is this method and formula that transforms a plain old boiled potato. Because of the quantity of salt in the water, it boils at a higher temperature, better cooking and developing the starches the potato contains.
When this happens, you have a creamier potato. And whoah is it creamy.
Tender, but not waterlogged; salty but not Dead-sea salty; salt potatoes are a revelation.
I have a third and final example of my powers of thought transference. Some are now asking what they would possibly do with four and a quarter pounds of cooked potatoes.
Well, my first answer is “eat them!”, but I understand that not everyone is feeding a regiment with each meal like I am. There are some mind-bendingly delicious applications for leftover salt potatoes.
- Home fries: Chop up leftover salt potatoes and fry in a heavy skillet with additional butter or bacon grease. You’ve never had better home fries in your entire life.
- Crash Hot Potatoes: The Pioneer Woman’s fabulous Down-Under treatment for potatoes becomes that much easier with leftover salt potatoes. It probably goes without saying, but I’ll say it anyway, you can ramp back on the salt you sprinkle over the smooshed, olive oiled and rosemaried potatoes before baking. They are salt potatoes, after all.
- Smashed Potatoes: Reheat your salt potatoes, smash lightly, add a splash of heavy cream, some garlic, black pepper and chopped herbs. Stir well with a wooden spoon, serve with a grilled steak or portabello mushroom and prepare to be very happy.
- Potato Salad: Cut chilled leftover salt potatoes into bite sized pieces, toss with mayonnaise, chopped onions and celery, a squirt of yellow mustard, freshly ground black pepper and stir. Voila! Almost instant potato salad.
- Cold Salt Potato Midnight Snack: Yes. You haven’t lived until you’ve hit the refrigerator after staying up too late to watch a movie, skewered a cold salt potato on a fork, and nibbled delicately until the potato has disappeared. Trust me.
There is one last item to cover in this salt potato discussion; that is the question of whether to toss with butter or let the butter melt and run down over the hot salt potatoes. I’m in the latter camp, because I like the slight salt crust to be accented by rivulets of melted butter.
I love dunking my salt potatoes in the butter that pools at the bottom of the bowl. In my opinion, tossing the hot potatoes with butter to cover them completely takes away a bit from the charm of salt potatoes. The melted butter obscures the salty outer dusting.
However -and I speak the gospel truth here- they’re still delicious that way. They’re still distinctively not your average boiled potato.
They’re still creamy and salty; they’re just covered with butter. That’s not a bad thing.
This recipe is a perfect illustration of how simplicity so often delivers the most refined, intense flavours. Eating salt potatoes -whether taking a bite from the end of the little gem and dragging it through the melted butter on the plate before biting again or licking the melted butter dripping down your fork and the side of your hand- is one summer’s purest joys.
Salt Potatoes
Ingredients
- 3 quarts of water
- 12 ounces fine salt approximately 1 1/2 cups
- 4 1/4 pounds one-to-two bite sized new white boiling potatoes *see notes, washed
- 1 stick cold butter 4 ounces, cut into 8 pieces
- Optional:
- Chopped parsley for garnish
Instructions
- Bring water to a boil in a large stockpot or soup pot over high heat.
- When water reaches the boil, stir in all of the salt.
- Lower the potatoes into the water, one or two at a time, taking care not to splash yourself.
- Return the water to a boil, lower heat to medium and simmer until the potatoes are tender, between 15 and 25 minutes, depending on the size of the potatoes. (**See notes for methods on testing the potatoes for doneness.)
- Pour the water and potatoes into a colander in the sink and leave to air dry for 5-10 minutes.
- Transfer the potatoes to a serving dish and dot with the pieces of butter.
- Serve as is or garnish with chopped parsley.
To Store Leftovers:
- Pour potatoes and butter from the bowl into a container with a tight fitting lid or a zipper top bag.
Recipe Notes
*Salt potato kits, sold all over Upstate New York, use a very specific size of potatoes; Size B, Grade US no. 2. While most grocery stores don't define their potatoes using this method, you can't go wrong buying small creamer potatoes that are one-or-two-biters. The shape of the potato doesn't matter at all. **To test your potatoes, use tongs to lift a large potato from the boiling water. A skewer plunged into the potato should pass through the potato completely if it is done.
Nancy says
Does it matter what type of fine salt you use (sea salt, kosher, etc.)?
Rebecca says
Nancy- The salt that comes in the packets in the kits is usually plain table salt. I’ve used both Kosher and plain table salt and I’ve been happy with both.
krysta says
you know i will be making these.
[email protected] Cutting Edge of Ordinary says
Thank you for sharing this recipe with us! I have heard of salt potatoes (I’m not too, too far from you) but I’ve never eaten one. Now I must make them. My hub is a potato (& salt) fanatic. He will love this recipe. I’ll be on a potato hunt this week for sure.
Please note I resisted the urge to use an Elf reference when posting this comment. 🙂
Wenderly says
I’m intrigued. Most definitely intrigued. I will be giving these salt potatoes a try. These sound tasty.
Tina says
I am from the West and have never heard of these and I am interested. Can you use those little red potatoes too? By the way can you tell me the secret to great polenta or do you have a good recipe?
Thx
Rebecca says
@Krysta- Oh, I know you will!
@Lisa- Oh, if you’re already a potato and salt fan you do need to try these. They’re *sigh* a little bit of heaven.
@Wenderly- That was my first reaction when we moved to the area. Now I’m a devotee.
@Tina- You can absolutely use little reds. The key is to get a boiling type potato. Thin skinned Waxy potatoes, small Yukon golds, white boiling potatoes, all would work well. I’d steer clear of Russets or the larger potatoes with the thick skins.
Aunt Tuna says
I knew what this was going to be about, and I thought I had emotionally prepared myself, however the sight of salt-crusted potatoes with butter melting around them just put me over the edge. I have salivated and it ain’t pretty.
Melissa says
People from less enlightened areas of the country have no idea what they’ve been missing. My fav leftover is a salt potato sandwich on pumpernickel with mayo.
Wendy Gunderson says
I was first introduced to salt potatoes at a clambake in the Syracuse area. What a treat to see how easy they are. Now that I’m in Texas, they’ll just have to adapt as a barbecue side. I think they’ll be perfect.
Thanks!
Andrea @ From the Bookshelf says
I love these! I haven’t made them in ages! Thank you for bringing it back to mind!
Kate says
I am born & raised in western NY (currently living in Rochester). It’s always amazing to me how many people have never heard of salt potatoes! I must make them at least 6 times every summer. They’re the perfect picnic food.
Katherine says
i have homegrown fingerling potatoes ready to harvest / how about them for salt potatoes ?
please say yes / smile / i cant wait to try these / thanks
Kate says
I saw your photo on TasteSpotting and sighed with longing. I grew up in Rochester and sure do miss those tasty little potatoes – I haven’t had them in years. You’re right – people from out of state just don’t understand!
MaryAnne says
Until moving to CNY a year and a half ago, I had never heard of salt potatoes. Being the good Midwesterner that I am, I could not imagine that there was a way to prepare potatoes that I did not know! One bite and we were all hooked…
Diana Vance says
I have never heard of these either. I grew up in Western PA, been living in the Hoosier Heartland for decades and have never come across them. I made them tonight for my guys, WOW! So simple, so GOOD!! Thank you!
CourtneyEliz says
Holy moly. So I live in Sweden and if anybody knows much about Sweden – these people freakin’ live off potatoes. My husband is a meatball and potato kind of guy and I, frankly, was so very sick of it until I had these salt potatoes last night. I have made potatoes every which way and I *seriously* thought I couldn’t eat any more. Ever. Well! I ate a TON of potatoes last night. They are just that good. Leftovers? Yeah, we don’t have any! Simple, cheap, delicious recipe..Definitely a keeper. Thank you for curing my potato sickness!
marigold larhette says
reading Blood Bones and Butter led me to this site!Great trip! Thank you!
Cliff says
Wow. These are good. I’ve made them a couple times now. I used baby red potatoes (all I could find at my local grocery). And I love them even without butter. Thanks for sharing!!
Cat says
These are awesome! I used Baby Reds also. First time I have ever enjoyed a cold ‘tater! Thank you!
Marietta Gould says
My hub is a potato (& salt) fanatic. So simple, so GOOD!! I ate a TON of potatoes last night.
Danielle says
I am from Alabama, but married a boy from NY, Baldwinsville, I had never had these until a visit to his family, I just assumed they were like any other boiled potato. I was WRONG!!! I have found these recentally in a local grocery store, labeled as Salt Potatoes. It looked exactly the same as the ones in NY. I bought them and cooked them immediately and oh my so good!
sheryl says
I live in Western NY and see these on the menu and in stores all the time. I had no idea that it was a western and upper NY thing. They really are very good. I like some parsley in my butter then roll the potatoes in it. Small yukon gold and small red potatoes work well. They sound so simple, but there is something about the flavor of being boiled in salted water that just works so well. Just bought some from the Farmer’s Market and making some for dinner.
Alice E. says
I’m a midwesterner and had never heard of these until I found your blog. Have really been enjoying it. I tried these and they were a definite hit with my husband. Yummy. I did cut down on the amount of potatoes and adjust the recipe to use less water and salt for just the two of us. But, why didn’t I find them listed under sides in the recipe list? I had to follow the link from the crash potatoes recipe to find them again.
Chocolate Lady says
I’m a California gal, and I promise, I didn’t have the expected reaction; you had me hooked 3 sentences in and I had to keep reading to find out what delectable, tasty bites I’ve been missing out on my entire life. I’ve never heard of potatoes cooked this way, and because I can’t wait until summer for new white boiling papas, I’m going to try this out using baby reds this weekend. I LOVE your blog!!! Thank you!
Jeremy says
Darn! I thought I invented Salt Potato Salad. I don’t salt the potatos, they stand on their own as a great creamy textured salad. I sometimes add some ranch and shredded cheddar to the mayo mixture. This is something I look forward to every summer. I had them for the first time at a Chiefs game at Alliance Bank Stadium and fell in love with them immediately. Thanks for the other tips!!
Rebecca says
🙂 They were actually invented at Cornell University in the Ag department by folks who were trying to figure out a way to make the culls palatable and something that people would buy! I know someone who was attending Cornell at the time!
Debbie says
No they were not invented at Cornell University. They were invented in Syracuse N.Y. where salt miners were trying to figure out a cheap but delicious way to feed the men who were working. They brined potatoes and served them with butter. Where are you getting your misinformation from?
Rebecca says
A proud Cornellian graduate shared that information with me. She said the actual MARKETING of salt potatoes was their brainchild. That the salt potatoes were invented by Syracuse miners IS true, but the marketing of the tiny size 1 creamers was a Cornell thing to make those baby culls useful that came up when digging the larger storage potatoes.
pelican says
These potatoes are awesome! I recently tried them for the time at my stepdaughters wedding. They had the fire department cater the wedding with a barbecue and let me tell you fire departments know how to cook! I was wondering what salt potatoes were and they are nothing short of delicious. You’ve got to try these little gems and they will sure be a part of my recipe collection!
Ori says
How would you reheat salt potatoes?
Rebecca says
You have a couple options… None of them will really keep the salt crust intact except for option A which is putting them in a shallow baking dish and baking them in a 350°F oven until heated through. You can also nuke ’em or put them in a covered saucepan with a half inch of water, bring to a boil, then lower heat and steam ’til heated through. The truth is, though, most Western New Yorkers eat the leftovers cold or as home fries~
Robby says
I have heard of these fabled potatoes, but not from anyone that could really explain how they are made. I think these would be fab for a barbeque I am doing for a large group this spring. Any thoughts (cautions, shocked replies) on using part butter and part bacon grease for the ‘dressing’ on these guys?
Rebecca says
The purists would say no and then secretly sneak them if they had bacon fat on them. 😀 I say try ’em small scale like that before you commit an entire batch. Worst case scenario? You make a seriously rockin’ batch of home fries from the leftovers!
Karly says
So, crazy story. I came across this recipe today and decided I had to make them for dinner tonight, but I was going to go buy new potatoes, because my tiny little grocery store does not carry your fancy creamer grade B whatever potatoes. It just doesn’t. The produce section is smaller than my living room and I’m in there every day and I would have noticed these little potatoes. So, I walked in and headed for where they keep the potatoes and there, on the shelf I look at every day, beckoning to me are little potatoes labeled Grade B Creamer Potatoes. I died. And I bought 800 bags of them and we are eating potatoes forever and ever, amen.
Debbie says
Salt potatoes did not start in Western N.Y. They started in Syracuse N.Y. (a.k.a. the salt city) which is in Central N.Y.
Rebecca says
Ah. I didn’t actually say they STARTED in Western New York. I said they started in Syrcause but were a fixture on the Western New York barbecue scene. Please don’t get so defensive!
Kara says
I tried them. I loved them. I’ll never go back!
Reay says
Been a Central NY’er my whole life and grew up on salt taters. I prefer to melt the butter on the side put five or six in a bowl break them open with a fork and drizzle the butter over them. Leaves a nice puddle of butter in the bottom for slam dunking. Another great leftover idea is to cube them up, melt a stick of butter in a 9 x 13 pan add a generous amount of Dinosaur BBQ Butt Rub, toss the taters in gently to coat and bake til lightly crispy. For those not from NY you could use any BBQ dry rub.
Angela says
I learned about this method about 10 or so years ago. I was working on the geneology of my husband’s family – Irish. And i came across information about it. I decided to treat it like eating crab legs and used little ramekins as little butter dipping bowls. I just put the ramekins in a toaster oven to melt the butter. Then we use fondue forks for the potatoes. Each person gets their own butter bowl. Dipping the whole thing in butter, once maybe twice is the best.
Denice J. Meyers says
We live in Western NY, south of Rochester. Love Salt Potatoes. The salt packet always seems finer than table salt. That is OK. My question is: Is Salt Potato salt the same as table salt? Seems so from what I have read. Please confirm; most interested in if iodized. Thanks.
Rebecca says
I’m almost certain that most of the salt potato packets contain kosher salt which is not iodized. Kosher salt is often slightly finer than table salt, too, in it’s fine form.
Reni says
Probably could grind any salt into fine with coffee/herb mill?
Uncle Ben says
Cook’s Country specifies non-iodized salt, but I don’t remember the reasoning behind it.
Reni says
Haha! Rebecca you are too funny! Love reading your recipes “Wow. Boiled potatoes with butter” and “Oookay. Boiled potatoes in salty water. Woopee!” I am going to make these today…yum yum yum.
Reni says
…No – wait – I will make them tomorrow and have them with our spiraled Ham…can’t wait!
Rebecca says
Ooooh, you will love these! Be advised they will spit a good deal of salty water around as they cook. Your stovetop will definitely need to be wiped down. 😀
Reni says
Bring it on salty potatoes! 🙂 I am so glad I found your site Rebecca, so informative and down right great food! I did buy your “Not Your Momma’s Canning Book” Am going through that right now, it is fantastic!
Rebecca says
I’m so glad you like it, Reni! It was a fun project for me! And yes to the salty potatoes! They are far and away my favourite way to have potatoes.
debc says
Melissa at Bless this Mess said we needed to try these. OMG! OMG! OMG! Like others, I found myself unable to stop eating these creamy little spuds! I was able to put 3 in the fridge for leftovers….but…they only survived until 11:55pm….and you are right…the perfect cold midnight munchie! Thanks for sharing this recipe! And…PS….love your book too…its a super fun read… the first recipe…moonshine…the second…bourbon….in a canning book…oh you rock!!!!
Rebecca says
Ohmygoodness, debc! Thank you so much. Salt Potatoes for the World! 😀
And thank you for your kind words about Not Your Mama’s Canning Book. I so appreciate them. I’d be honoured if you’d leave a review for it on Amazon!
Cindy Pikulski says
How would you make them in a slow cooker ? With the water it without ?
Rebecca says
I would honestly not attempt them in the slow cooker. I would only do on a stovetop. The issue is that it needs to boil violently and a slow cooker can -at best- provide a slow roll. The violent boiling is crucial to the final texture, so I would do them a day ahead; worst case scenario.
Cindy Pikulski says
How do you make them in a crockpot? with. Water or without?
Joshua Crosby says
And a pox on your house if you crush these and then add the butter. Savages!
The only accepted way to eat them is to stab with a utensil, submerge into butter, stick in your mouth.
Mona Heck says
You’re right. Salt potatoes are amazing. They were invented in Syracuse, NY. (The salt city) by Irish immigrants working in the salt mines. Central NY, not Western NY. We don’t take credit for Buffalo wings or beef on wick or sponge candy. Please give credit where it’s due
Jaci says
I grew up eating these delicious potatoes. Only difference, we ate them by dipping them in melted butter. Soooooo gooood!
Rebecca says
Ooooh yeah! I love to dunk ’em, too!
Sharon says
Sounds wonderful. If you pour melted butter over the potatoes, does all the salt com off.
Rebecca says
Hi Sharon- Some of the salt does indeed come off, but some stays on it! That’s why I prefer to dip rather than pour these days.
Linda Johnson says
Can’t wait ti try these patatoes
CHRISTINE FRUMEN says
Delicious! I made a smaller amount , less than 2 # of small potatoes including the purple ones. I used 6 cups of water and 1 cup of salt. Mine were eaten hot, warm and cold and each was scrumptious! Loved your information about these. Not for someone watching their sodium but much better as a midnight snack as a bowl of ice cream!
Rebecca says
I’m with you on this as a midnight snack, Christine! So glad you loved it!
Cindy says
I was telling my husband about salt potatoes, but it’s been decades since I made them, so I looked it up and found your post. I first bought a kit, probably at Wegman’s, back when I was living with friends in our first apartment during college. Thanks for confirming it was not a figment of my imagination, and apparently quite a staple of western NY.
Rebecca says
You’re very welcome, Cindy! I’m so glad you loved them! And thank you, too, for taking the time to review the recipe. I do appreciate it.
Judy says
I’m from the South and have never heard of potatoes prepared this way. My question is this: do the salt potatoes taste salty?
Rebecca says
They don’t taste weirdly salty… just about the right amount of salt, but the salt really changes the texture of the inside without making them overly salty! It’s really hard to explain. 🙂
Laura says
I’m making salt potatoes for a crowd. I plan to cook them as usual on the morning of the event, but do you think it will work to keep them warm in a crock pot until the luncheon? I need to be able to transport them. Butter will need to be on the side! Thanks.
Rebecca says
Hi Laura- I think that’ll work. You might lose some of the salt crust to condensation, but they’ll still be delicious!
Laura says
Thank you!