Friends: I’m participating in the 30 Days of Gratitude on the Foodie With Family facebook page. Won’t you join me when you can and share a little or a big something you’re grateful for every day? And if every day is too much in your life right now, how about just whenever you can? Click here to be part of a thankfulness movement!
I’m going to start this post with a confession and spend the rest of it haranguing you into making this my way. Sounds fun, right? Let’s get started.
My confession: I don’t like baked macaroni and cheese. Right now there are two groups of people reading this. Group A is gasping and fanning themselves and ready to storm me and revoke my foodie card. Group B is saying, “Big whoop.” It’s okay. I understand. I often feel like I SHOULD like it since it’s a little of a lot of things I love in one package. I just don’t. It’s a texture thing.
I DO, however, ADORE creamy mac and cheese and I’m OVER-THE-MOON in love with shells and cheese. There’s just something so awfully cute about shells and I love the way they trap all the good saucy stuff. What I didn’t love about that, though, was how ever-loving messy the process was with the bechamel in one pan and the noodles in another and the blah blah blah. Then a few years ago, I read my beloved White on Rice couple’s creamy stove top mac and cheese recipe and the clouds- they parted. They cooked the pasta IN the milk. Well, duh. Why didn’t anyone ever think of that before?
Over the past couple of years, I’ve tinkered with the recipe to reflect my family’s preferences. While there are many versions of stove-top creamy mac and cheese out there, this one is our favourite (and if you pile my Taco Mac Hack on top, it’s garner-cheers-at-the-table good.)
I’ve made countless versions of this one-pot mac. I know what DOES work and what DOESN’T. I am giving you my version today: the one that never fails us. But here’s where the haranguing comes into play. This recipe is easy IF YOU DO IT EXACTLY AS I SAY. If you’ve been around here for long, you know I don’t say that often. When I say it, I mean it. Of course, there are still a couple of items up for negotiation (like what milk you use and whether you pursue the taco mac angle or go au naturel. The noodles not the nudie, if you follow my meaning…)
Here are the rules:
- Choose your milk: You can absolutely choose to use skim, one-percent, two-percent or whole milk here. That is not going to effect the end texture as much as how decadent the final product is. That’s a choice.
- Use small shells: not medium shells, not elbow macaroni, not ditalini, not spaghetti, not linguine… You get the picture. This recipe was refined using small shells. And yes, it really DOES make a difference here. I tried doing this using equal weights of other types of pasta. Sometimes it worked, sometimes it didn’t. It worked EVERY time with the shells.
- Use half Monterey Jack cheese and half extra sharp Cheddar. The reasons are multiple. Monterey Jack is a smoother melting cheese than Cheddar and it’s milder. Combining the two in equal parts gives you the tang of Cheddar and the smooth gooey loveliness of Monterey Jack. Win/win… And while we’re on the subject of cheese.
- Grate your own cheese. No, I know. The bags of pre-grated stuff are super convenient. I use them from time to time, too. The thing is, the little shreds of cheese in those bags are coated with powder that keeps them from sticking together. Handy for pre-grated cheese, but not so wonderful when you’re melting it and WANT it to come together. Just hike those socks up and grate the cheese. It’s a one-pot meal, you’re still a head of the game even after you mess up the cheese grater. And speaking of cheese, make sure you have it grated before you start cooking. Why? Because you…
- DO NOT WALK AWAY FROM THE POT. Heck, you probably shouldn’t even stop stirring. You’re using the starch coating the pasta as thickening power in the sauce. As the pasta cooks, that starch goes into the milk (as the milk is being absorbed by the pasta) to make it thick and creamy. Thick and creamy likes to stick to pans. Things that like to stick to pans like to scorch. Scorched creamy shells and cheese is a sad, sad thing. Just keep stirring. It’s a small price to pay for fabulous creamy mac made in just one pot. You’ll be so glad you did.
Alright, that’s it for my brow-beating. Is anyone still with me? If so, let me tell you about my Taco Mac Hack. It’s so simple it hardly counts as a recipe, so it’s a freebie here. Top your One-Pot Creamy Shells and Cheese with leftover taco meat or browned Mexican-style chorizo and a couple candied jalapeños on top. Ta da! You’ve hacked your mac into Taco Mac. If you’re the ketchup on your mac and cheese type, add a dollop of salsa!
One-Pot Creamy Shells and Cheese Plus Bonus Taco Mac HackRate Recipe
- 1 pound small shells pasta Do NOT use medium shells.
- 4 cups milk plus extra, in case!
- 3 tablespoons butter
- 1/2 teaspoon ground mustard powder
- 2 teaspoons kosher salt
- 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder
- 1/2 teaspoon onion powder
- 1 cup grated Monterey Jack cheese
- 1 cup grated extra sharp Cheddar cheese
- freshly ground pepper to taste
Optional for Taco Mac:
- Fully cooked taco meat or browned chorizo
- Candied Jalapenos
- Add the small shells, milk, butter, mustard, salt, garlic and onion powder to a large saucepan over medium heat. Stirring nearly constantly and taking care to scrape the spoon across the bottom of the pan to prevent sticking and scorching, slowly bring the mixture to a simmer then drop the heat to LOW. Don't forget this or you'll be sorry!
- Continue stirring and simmering the pasta for about 15 minutes, or until the milk is almost completely absorbed. Test a piece of pasta (carefully, though, because this stuff is MOLTEN at this point.) If the pasta isn't fully cooked and the milk is almost gone, add more milk in -1/4 cup at a time- until the pasta is fully cooked. This will add a small amount of cooking time (3-5 minutes) to the overall cooking time.
- Remove the pan from the heat and stir in the grated cheese.
- Put a lid on the pan and let it rest, undisturbed for 3-5 minutes. Give it one more stir and taste. Add the black pepper to taste and serve hot.
- Leftovers can be stored in the refrigerator in a tightly lidded container and heated up with a splash of milk in the microwave or in a saucepan.
To Make Taco Mac:
- Sprinkle re-heated taco meat or crispy brown chorizo over bowls of hot Creamy Shells and Cheese and top with candied jalapenos if desired.
Nutritional information is an estimate and provided to you as a courtesy. You should calculate the nutritional information with the actual ingredients used in your recipe using your preferred nutrition calculator.
did you make this recipe?
Make sure to tag @foodiewithfam on Instagram and #hashtag it #foodiewithfamily so I can check it out!
Joan Wissert says
To quote my cheese-loving husband “This is a keeper! It’s the best macaroni and cheese I’ve ever had!” I’ve meant to try it for a while, and finally did. Thank you for this wonderful creation!
That is fantastic, Joan! I’m so glad you all enjoyed it!
I cannot wait to try this! My family does not like baked mac & cheese, they want the creamy stove top mac & cheese. I have tried a few different recipes with varied success. On my list for this weekend.
Rebecca, this is the most decadent dish I have ever tasted and holy cow SO worth the time it took to cook it.
Thanks for the great recipe. My family is going to think I’m invincible. <3
Yeehah!! I’m so glad you loved it!
I’m not sure I’m reading this right– you cook the pasta in the milk? Or is it a pound of already cooked shells? Also, I want to make this for a kid party — do you think it would be ok to double it for 15 kids?
You read it right! Cook the pasta in the milk. I’d recommend that you give it a run at this amount before doubling it so you get the feel for it. Having to test (read: eat) a batch of Mac and cheese? I call that nice work. 🙂
Randa Lea says
Tried this tonight and didn’t have a lot of luck. I had to add milk several times and finally started adding water trying to get the pasta cooked. The seasoning is good, but the pasta is mushy. I think I’ll try again and partially cook my pasta in water, drain and add back to the pan with milk to finish cooking. Any other advice for me?
Ellen Renee says
Fabulous! Thank you :o)
made this tonight and it is very easy and so simple 🙂
Wow. If the concept works for risotto (let the starch thicken the sauce), why not for pasta? Brilliant. I realize this is sacrilegious, but is it possible to sprinkle some panko and parm on top and pop it under the broiler for a quick crust? (I can go either way, but my guys are strictly on the baked side.)
RACHEL: A general rule is 1 oz. of cheese = 1/4 cup grated. (I’m a cookbook editor. It comes up a lot.)
I hate to admit how exciting the idea of cooking the pasta in the milk is!! Cheesey noodles is a top favourite in this house. In fact, I made them yesterday, with small shells! As you have to stir the cheese sauce anyway – this is a winner. Can’t wait to try this one out. Thanks!
Yumm! Totally with you on the no baked mac and cheese. So I will definitely give this a try!
How much of a block (or ounces) is the cheese before grating to get one cup? One of my favorite dishes is pasta and peas made with tiny shells, (medium works in a pinch). There is a recipe in Lidia’s family table that is very good although I usually make the simpler version from a local PBS cookbook.
kate C. says
Does the brand of pasta matter? I could see that it would be possible for certain brands of ‘small’ shells to be slightly thicker/larger/smaller/thinner than other brands which might mess up your perfect formula, right?
Just to be safe, what brand(s) do you use?
I have tested this recipe using DaVinci small shells pasta! I’d be inclined to think that most small shells would be great, but that is what I’ve used.
kate C. says
Great! Thanks! I’m still looking for an awesome mac n cheese recipe, haven’t been impressed by the baked ones I’ve tried either, so hopefully this will be the one!
I’m with ya, baked macaroni and cheese is not for me. I’m definately going to try this, but shredding cheese is more work than I normally put into mac and cheese, I’m a velveeta fan cuz it melts nice and smooth and not oily. But this sounds so good I bet its worth the extra time!
Elizabeth from the Berkshires says
I don’t suppose that, in the course of experimenting, you tried any sorts of gluten free pasta? My personal favorite is corn pasta. It sounds amazing…
DeeDee V. says
oh my goodness…this looks amazing. I am trying to get my boys over their horrible preference for the boxed stuff and I think this just might do it.
Jeeze, what do you have against ditalini? ha ha
I’m with group A but I’m willing to give this a chance!
Bev @ Bev Cooks says
Dyyyyying. This looks incredz.