When I was small, my mom made strawberry freezer jam every year during Michigan’s brief and glorious strawberry season.
It was my mom’s thing: her annual food preservation pièce de résistance. She scattered packets and boxes of pectin thither and yon, she mashed berries with the bottoms of drinking glasses, her potato masher, and anything else she could fit into her bowl. Her blonde hair had strawberry streaks, her hands were fuchsia , and she smelled like a strawberry patch for days on end. True to her style, she never measured (measuring was a creativity killer and the man’s way of keeping her down*) but somehow it always turned out to be the best thing we had eaten all year.
*Power to the people! Or Up with the People! Oh, geez. I can never get that right. I’m sorry, Mom.
I played around with cooked jam over the years, but it never drew close to the juicy, soft-set, fresh-from-the-field taste of strawberry freezer jam. Is it because of my formative years and my mom’s painting the kitchen with strawberries? Oh, probably…
I want my kids to have that same memory when they’re adults. The full sensory memory of watching their mom make jam: smelling, tasting, feeling the ripe strawberries… The anticipation of the flavour when a jar is fetched from the freezer and twisted open… I want them to have a vision of me with strawberry streaks on my cheeks (since my hair is not light enough to show it), fuchsia hands and smelling like a strawberry patch. Of course, their Mama measures obsessively, but every childhood is a little different, isn’t it? At least I got the important stuff in there.
…And my jam, well, now it has two crucial ingredients that my Mom didn’t put in hers. Balsamic vinegar and fresh thyme.
I know it might sound bizarre, but this is the most strawberry-y jam ever. If you can imagine the most fresh, juicy, flavour-packed strawberry you’ve ever had that is multiplied by about fifteen, you have an idea of what this tastes like.
You may already know that adding balsamic vinegar to strawberries boosts the flavour, but did you know that infusing it with thyme has a similar effect? And when you add balsamic AND thyme, you get knock-you-flat strawberryness. Whizz-bang, ka-pow, shammalammadingdong strawberry power is what Strawberry Balsamic Thyme Freezer Jam is.
I was already a big fan of the strawberry/thyme combination thanks to my good buddy, Krysta over at Evil Chef Mom and the strawberry/balsamic combination thanks to, um, I don’t know what. I first read about combining all of them in jam form, though, over on Serious Eats when Lucy Baker made a batch that sounded tantalizing.
When I read Lucy’s post, I knew that was going to happen as soon as the sleepy New York strawberries finally burst onto the scene.
A friend brought a whole flat of strawberries my way two days ago and thankfully, I remembered my previous plans. Mercifully. Appreciatively. I am so grateful that I remembered those plans because this is the best strawberry jam I’ve ever shoveled shamelessly into my mouth by the spoonful.
Best. Strawberry. Jam. Ever.
(…except for my Mom’s…)
A Note About the Pectin I Use:
Pomona’s Universal Pectin is well worth any trouble you have finding it. You can double, triple or quadruple recipes (or more if you have appropriately sized vessels for preparing massive batches of jam) with no ill-effects, unlike most “normal” pectins. It has no funky preservatives, additives, and allows you to make the best jam you’ve ever eaten with much less sugar than your average pectin (even the low-sugar varieties) or no sugar at all. I’m getting nothing out of this, the Pomona’s people don’t even know I exist *sniffsniff*. I seriously believe their product is the best and have years worth of experience to back up my claims.
Yes, it looks expensive. I mean honestly, $4-$6 per box? Yipes! But if you break it down, you’ll realize that each box has enough pectin powder to make 2-4 batches of jam. That works out to about $3.00 per batch (calculating for liberal use) which is equal to or better than the most common commercial pectins. When you add the convenience of larger batches to the equal or better price per batch, I think the comparative value makes Pomona’s the much better bet.
You can use a standard commercial pectin to make Strawberry Balsamic Thyme Freezer Jam (see recipe notes) if necessary, but I stand by Pomona’s!
Strawberry Balsamic Thyme Freezer JamRate Recipe
- 4 cups mashed hulled strawberries
- 2 tablespoons balsamic vinegar
- 2 tablespoons fresh lemon juice
- ¾-2 cups granulated sugar
- 1 tablespoon Pomona’s Universal Pectin Powder + ¼ cup Pomona’s Calcium Water *See notes, or more, if necessary.
- 1 cup water
- 3 sprigs fresh thyme
- Prepare freezer-safe jars or containers with airtight lids that can hold up to 6 cups of jam. (**See Notes)
- Stir together sugar, crushed berries, balsamic vinegar, calcium water, and lemon juice in a large mixing bowl. Add sprigs of thyme to water and bring to a boil. Strain and measure ¾ cup into a blender carafe. Sprinkle the pectin powder over the boiling water in the blender and add the lid. Open the vent on the blender lid, cover with a doubled dish towel or wash cloth, and blend on high for 1-2 minutes or until the pectin powder is completely dissolved. Scrape into the berry mixture and stir well.
- Pour the pectin water into the berry mixture and stir very well to combine. It should start to gel visibly. If it does not gel (although the gel will be much more soft-set than cooked jam), add 1 teaspoon of calcium water and blend well, repeating if necessary.
- Ladle into prepared containers to within ½” of the rims, fix the lids on tightly and freeze immediately.
Nutritional information is an estimate and provided to you as a courtesy. You should calculate the nutritional information with the actual ingredients used in your recipe using your preferred nutrition calculator.
did you make this recipe?
Make sure to tag @foodiewithfam on Instagram and #hashtag it #foodiewithfamily so I can check it out!
Rebecca, HELP! I’ve never made any kind of jam etc in my life. This may be a stupid question but… Is this 4 cups of strawberries, mashed? Or 4 cups of mashed strawberries? Big difference!
Hi Toni- That’s a great question, actually! It’s 4 cups of mashed strawberries. 🙂
Sereima Tuiketei says
what is the substitute for pectin? I cant seem to find this in my local supermarket.
Hey there, Sereima! You can mail order this particular pectin! Or if you have a health food store nearby, you can usually find Pomona’s Universal Pectin there. I’ve even ordered it from Amazon!
Interesting that Pomona’s pectin works for you. I used it a couple of years ago with Michigan strawberries and it absolute would not gel. What a disappointment and a waste of gorgeous berries and mMY “thyme”.
That’s a bummer! I would’ve gone back in with more Pomona’s and tried thickening it up some more. If I had a whole batch of Michigan strawberries, I would cry if they didn’t gel!
This was a sensational recipe! I used it with the strawberries we just picked and wow! You can’t taste the balsamic and thyme by themselves but it makes the strawberry flavor pop. I used just 1.5 cups of sugar and I think next time I’ll cut that down by half a cup. It really doesn’t need much sugar at all. I love that about this recipe. And I’m a Pomona’s convert now too. Thanks!
Thank you so much, Carol! And thank you, too, for the excellent review! This is by far my favourite freezer jam recipe.
Joan Thompson says
I have a lovely Strawberry Balsamic from EVOO in Denver. It’s been drizzled over fresh stawberries (they even perk up the hard, flavorless California variety) or used to make the dressing for a spinach strawberry salad. Would it be over kill?
I don’t think it would be overkill but I’d be loathe to part with something so delicious sounding! 😀
Samantha McTague says
Can this jam be preserved using a water bath method instead of freezing?
Unfortunately, no. I’m not saying you can’t make a balsamic thyme cooked jam, I’m just saying this particular recipe won’t work for it.
I was so inspired by this, Rebecca! I did make it, with peaches. I just can’t wait to try it with some strawberries too! Thank you! P~
RE: Pomona’s calcium water… In your packet of Pomona’s, there is going to be a smaller envelope of the powder to make calcium water. You’re all set, Stephanie!
Kimberly- Hmmmmm… Maybe you could simmer the lemon juice and thyme together in larger amounts? Just a thought.
Kimberly :) says
So, I got liquid pectin on sale last week. (bargain CHEER!) I made two batches at the same time. It worked beautifully. The only thing I can’t figure out is this: How can I get the thyme infused with the liquid pectin since there is no water added to the recipe? I tried nuking the pectin and lemon juice with the thyme but I’m not convinced it added any thyme-i-ness.
Yeah, yeah, I know I shoulda bought the Pomona’s but…liquid pectin on SALE? At $2.29? You know I had to buy that.
Please speak, oh wise one…
Just purchased some of Pomona’s Universal Pectin via their website based on your recommendation. I’m excited to try it! Quick question…if I made this recipe is the Pomona’s calcium water essential or can normal water be substituted? Thanks!
Amy | She Wears Many Hats says
I’ve made strawberry jam but never strawberry balsamic. I wanna.
This looks amazing. I really want to start doing some canning and making my own jam. I just might have to try this!
Just wondering if you think I should purchase some of those great big enormous strawberries from the store, you know, Rhymes with pj’s… Because there aren’t any actual fresh strawberries where I live. And also, how many berries do you think it will take to make a batch? 50? 75? 141? I have never done this before, except for one time I tried to make some cooked strawberry something, but it tasted sort of burnt and I wasn’t really sure what I had done wrong.
Beth S. says
Seriously? The day AFTER I’m done processing some 16# of strawberries? Sigh… back to the fields I go! This looks scrumptious!