Evil Genius, Sr.’s Slathering Barbecue Sauce

The Evil Genius Sr.'s Slathering Barbecue Sauce smoky, tangy, sweet, and perfect for brushing layer after layer.

When it comes to barbecue sauces, I’m going to admit I have a bit of a neurotic streak. Big surprise, right? When I learned how easy it was to make my own all these years ago, it was hard to walk into a store and pay mucho deniro for the cruddy bottles of glorified ketchup they were selling. Honestly, the first or second ingredient in almost every single brand was high fructose corn syrup. GACK. And then, when higher end barbecue sauce became available, I still couldn’t pay for it because I knew how tasty my homemade stuff was. (There is one notable exception, and that’s the Dinosaur Barbecue Sensuous Slathering sauce, but I digress…)

Important sidebar: My husband recently went on a business trip to Georgia. While there, he was able to spend some time with his dad and eat a couple of meals at his home. His dad -a phenomenal cook- made two extremely memorable meals for him. One of grilled lamb chops and one of smoky ribs. My hubby, The Evil Genius, raved about the rub on his dad’s ribs. He raved about the SAUCE on his dad’s ribs. He raved. Naturally, I called his dad to ask for the recipe.

His dad explained that he usually makes a thinner, more North Carolina style sauce for his ribs, and rattled off his list of ingredients for me. He gave me quantities on four or so of the ingredients and told me to add the rest in the quantities in which I liked them. Yes, sir. I call that license to play with my food.

Because I intended to make the barbecue sauce for chicken, and I think of chicken as a job for more St. Louis style barbecue sauce (read: a stickier, more visible end product), I opted to alter my father-in-law’s sauce by omission; I left out the water. That is the ONLY change I made to his sauce and man is it ever good. It’s not stodgy and spreadable thick, but is instead the perfect thickness for brushing on and caramelizing layer after layer of tangy, sweet, slightly spicy, sticky sauce. In short, UHNNNNNNNNNNNNGH, it’s good.

The Evil Genius Sr.'s Slathering Barbecue Sauce smoky, tangy, sweet, and perfect for brushing layer after layer.

Cook’s Notes

  •  This is a pretty low-effort recipe with a pretty high payoff, but you still can’t walk away from it and let it go unattended. You don’t have to stir much, but it can go from perfect to scorched pretty easily if you ignore it. Just hang out in the kitchen. Be within sniffing and listening range of the pot at all times. Wash a few dishes, you’ll be fine.
  • The sauce is good for up to two weeks in the refrigerator. If you need to stretch it out a bit further, freeze it in single meal portions for later. It’ll be fine for up to three months in the freezer.
  • Before anyone asks, let me address whether or not this is canning friendly. In a word, probably. Long version: it hasn’t been tested. It’s probably acidic enough, it’s definitely thin enough… Like I said, though, it hasn’t been properly tested. I’d probably be comfortable pressure canning it and serving it to my family, but we have no immune deficiencies, so if you decide to try it, do so at your own risk.
5 from 1 reviews
Evil Genius, Sr.’s Slathering Barbecue Sauce
  • 1 cup ketchup
  • 1 cup apple cider vinegar
  • 1 cup brown sugar
  • ½ cup Jack Daniels honey Dijon mustard
  • 3 tablespoons soy sauce
  • 3 tablespoons Chinese pepper paste (Chili Garlic Sauce or Sambal Oelek)
  • 4 cloves garlic, peeled and minced
  • 1 teaspoon liquid smoke
  • ½ teaspoon cayenne pepper, optional
  1. Combine all ingredients and bring to a boil, stirring until the sugar is dissolved. Drop the heat to low and simmer, stirring frequently, until it has darkened in colour and reduced to be slightly thicker, about 15 minutes. When done, it should coat the back of a spoon and leave a trail when you draw your finger (CAREFULLY!) through it.
  2. Use immediately or store in a tightly lidded jar or container for up to two weeks in the refrigerator. This can be frozen for later use.


    • says

      Generally I find it in one of three places in the grocery store: 1) near the pickles, 2) near the mustard/mayo/ketchup, or 3) near the seasonings. Sometimes it is sold as ‘liquid smoke seasoning’ or ‘liquid hickory seasoning’… I can even get it at the tiny grocery in town near me!

  1. Beth says

    Jack Daniels honey Dijon mustard?? I don’t think I’ve seen that here in Australia. How different is it to regular honey mustard (which I think ours tends to be whole seeds rather than Dijon – but still very nice). Any suggestions for best substitutes?

    • says

      It’s a smoother honey Dijon. If you can’t find it, you can make your own by combining the smooth Dijon with a little honey and a tiny splash of bourbon or whiskey!


  1. […] Exhibit A: Stage one of his two stages. This is our charcoal grill. He removed the grate on the far end of the grill to make room for his chimney starter with a grill basket positioned over it to hold wood chunks. The idea was that the chimney starter would hold the hot coals to one side, directing the heat upward and toward the soaked hardwood chunks generating a large amount of smoke. After about two hours -when the skin had become golden and the fat was running from under it- he switched it over to a low gas grill. He let it go for about a half an hour, flipping from time to time and watching it to avoid flare-ups from the fat running off of the chicken. Then he began his ‘sequence’ of brushing on the sauce working from one end of the grill to the other, then flipping each piece and starting again. He continued this until each piece had been lacquered to sticky, tangy, mahogany perfection. Of course, he used his father’s barbecue sauce: The Evil Genius Sr.’s Slathering Barbecue Sauce. […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Rate this recipe: