Blueberry Tiramisu

Truthfully, this dessert should be called ‘Why I almost ceased being a dog-owner’. But I’ll start at the beginning…

A good friend -who shall remain unnamed since she played hooky from work to come play in the kitchen with me- and I spent a couple hours working on this masterpiece. We made the ladyfingers from scratch.  The mascarpone cream?  It was made of homemade mascarpone* and eggs from my chickens.  The blueberry compote was crafted from blueberries that the boys and I had picked and frozen last August. The homemade orange syrup for dunking the cookies was mixed with equally homemade Grand Marnier*.

*Show of hands, please.  Who wants to know how to make homemade mascarpone and/or Grand Marnier?  I’ll leave it up to you folks, but I’ll say this.  You can make 2 pounds of homemade mascarpone for about $6.00 and a quart of Grand Marnier for about the same amount of money. Any takers?  Tell me in the comments.

We assembled our tiramisu, popped it in the refrigerator and sat on easy chairs with our feet up to solve the world’s problems over a cuppa the finest.  Well, we tried anyway.  We didn’t get a whole lot further than discussing whether Kevin Gillespie (from Top Chef) was every bit as cool as he seemed on the show or whether he was actually cooler.  (Result: Cooler.  Definitely.)

We helped ourselves to dainty servings -due mainly to the fact that we ate the entire time the tiramisu ‘settled’ in the chill chest-  and ate it in raptures.

While I waved good-bye to *Whoops!  Almost said her name!* I fantasized about the size of the serving I would eat after the boys were in bed for the night.  I had it all planned out.

I would put a fluffy down blanket around my shoulders and tuck myself into the corner of the couch with a sinfully large bowl of the tiramisu and my copy of “Right ho, Jeeves!”

The Evil Genius came down from his lab and grabbed a large bowlful of tiramisu.  Since it was a bitterly cold day, he popped the lid on the trifle dish and sat it out on the porch to stay cold.  Then ‘it’ happened.  He leapt from his chair and ran toward the door with a look of panic on his face.  The cause of alarm became clear when I heard two things at the same time; Monsieur Evil yelling, “HAMBONE!” and the sound of a trifle dish skittering across the porch floor.

My 85-pound hound dog who is not under-fed by any stretch of the imagination ate my tiramisu.

And I have never wanted to own a dog less in my entire life.  Unless you count the time he ate my triple batch of lemon curd…

My plans for the evening flew out the front door along with a few well-aimed expletives at the dog.

My mother asked the next day whether the dog had experienced any discomfort from eating the better part of a very rich dessert.  My response?

“I sure hope so.”

At least I got a couple pictures to help me mourn…

For a printer-friendly version of this recipe minus the dog-related sob-story and pictures, click here!

Blueberry Tiramisu

Ingredients for ‘The Dunk':

  • 1 clementine or tangerine, washed carefully
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 1 cup water
  • 1/3 cup Grand Marnier or other orange liqueur

Ingredients for Mascarpone Cream:

  • 4 large eggs, separated
  • 1 pound mascarpone (This is about 2 cups of mascarpone.)
  • 3/4 cup plus 2 Tablespoons granulated sugar

Ingredients for Blueberry Compote:

  • 3 cups frozen or fresh blueberries
  • 1/2 cup water
  • 2 Tablespoons cornstarch or arrowroot powder
  • 1/2 cup granulated sugar
  • the zest of one orange or 1/2 teaspoon orange extract

Additional ingredients:

  • 50 ladyfinger cookies, homemade or purchased
  • fresh blueberries and orange zest, optional for garnish

This is not complicated, but it helps streamline the process if it is done in order.  To simplify, I’ll number each step of the process.

1. Begin by creating the syrup that will be used to moisten the ladyfingers; referred to hereafter as ‘the dunk’. Add the cup of sugar to the cup of water in a small saucepan. Stir until the sugar is dissolved and bring to a full-rolling boil.  As soon as it begins boiling, remove from heat. Make several cuts in the clementine or tangerine so that it is sliced deeply enough to release some of the juice, but not deeply enough to break up the fruit.  Gently drop the clementine into the syrup, cover with a tight fitting lid and let it steep and cool for 30 minutes.  After 30 minutes, fish the fruit out, gently squeeze over the bowl and discard the fruit.  Pour syrup into a mid-sized bowl, stir in the Grand Marnier and place in the refrigerator to chill completely…

2. Make the blueberry compote. In a small bowl, stir together the 1/2 cup of sugar and 2 Tablespoons of cornstarch or arrowroot powder.  Toss with the blueberries and orange zest (or orange extract) in a medium saucepan.  Add the water and stir over medium-low heat until the blueberries start to give up some of their juices.  When there is more liquid in the pan, raise the heat to medium or medium-high and continue stirring until the blueberries begin to burst and simmer.  Allow to simmer for 3 minutes, stirring constantly.  Remove from the heat and chill in the refrigerator until cold all the way through.

3.  Prepare the mascarpone cream. Carefully crack and separate the yolks and whites from your large eggs.  Place the yolks and 3/4 cup of sugar into the bowl of your stand mixer or a large mixing bowl.  Using the whisk attachment, whip on medium-high speed until the yolk mixture looks thick, creamy and light-yellow.  Add the mascarpone all at once and whip on medium-high speed until evenly combined, about 2 minutes.  If using the stand-mixer, transfer to a large mixing bowl and set in the refrigerator.  If using a large mixing bowl and hand-mixer, simply put the bowl into the refrigerator and turn your attention to the whites.

Mega Important Tip: If you are using the stand-mixer, carefully wash and dry the bowl and whisk attachment before proceeding!

Whip the egg-whites on high with the whisk attachment on your stand mixer until they form soft peaks.  (In other words, when you raise the whisk from the egg whites it should form a little curlicue on top that looks like the tip of a warm Hershey’s Kiss.) With the mixer still running on high, add the remaining two tablespoons of sugar.  Run for one minute, stop the mixer to scrape down the sides, and return to high until firm peaks form. (This means that when you raise the whisk from the egg whites, you should be able to recognize exactly where it left the egg whites and there should be no droopy curlicue.  The whites should be very shiny and glossy at this point.

Use a spatula to scrape about 1/3 of the beaten egg whites onto the mascarpone mixture.  Use a whisk to incorporate the whites.  This lightens the mascarpone cream a bit so that you can more easily fold the remaining whites into it.  Scrape the rest of the beaten whites onto the mascarpone cream.  Use a rubber or silicone spatula to fold the whites into the cream. Don’t panic!  While it sounds futzy, it’s really easy to fold egg whites into heavier mixtures.  The best way to do this is to picture your mixing bowl as a clock.  Insert the spatula, blade side down, into the center of the mixture and gently plunge it to the bottom of the bowl.   Pull the spatula back toward six o’clock.  When you hit the edge of the  bowl, rotate the spatula so that the flat part scrapes against the bowl.  Turn the spatula back blade side up at a 45-degree angle.  Lift the spatula, and the contents on top of it and gently turn it over.  Rotate the bowl about 15 minutes (a quarter turn) and repeat until there are no little white ‘clumps’ of egg white remaining. By this point, you should have an even, creamy and fluffy mascarpone cream.  Place this, lightly covered, into the refrigerator until you’re ready to proceed (but no longer than an hour in advance!)

4. Time to assemble!  Plunge the ladyfinger cookies, one at a time, into ‘The Dunk’ and count to 2.  Lift for an additional 2-count to let extra syrup drip away and then arrange cookies snugly over the bottom of your trifle dish or serving dish.  Scoop about 1/4 of the blueberry compote onto the ladyfingers and spread toward the edges.  Top with 1/4 of the mascarpone cream and spread toward the edges.  Repeat the layers -dunked ladyfingers, blueberry compote, mascarpone cream- until you run out of one item or space to fill. Tightly cover the dish and refrigerate for at least 2 hours prior to serving.

5. The payoff: time to eat! Scoop into serving dishes and eat as is or garnish with fresh blueberries and orange zest.


  1. says

    Holy cow, girl… this looks amazing. I assume I could sub some OJ for the Grand Marnier to make it alcohol-free? BTW, I would love to know how to make homemade mascarpone cheese!

  2. Mandy says

    Yes! I want to know how to make the homemade mascarpone and Grand Marnier… I have just recently found your site and I love it!
    thanks, and keep all the good stuff coming!

  3. Jackie Hibbard says

    Oh my gosh, this looks awesome! Hambone is a lot like my dog Ashley who would have done the same thing. I’m going to try this soon! And I’d love to learn how to make Grand Marnier. So proud of you Beccy!

  4. says

    I still feel the urge to throttle him. Still painful, just reading about it. Ugh.

    And how the heck do you make homemade Grand Marnier?? I’m still cooking/baking with alcohol, with no issue, and will continue to do so. Maybe not vodka. 😉

  5. Rebecca says

    Mom- You want ‘im?

    Natalie- Thank you! You can absolutely substitute orange juice for the Grand Marnier, but you could also consider using pineapple juice as a nice substitute.

    Katie- You betcha! I’m on it.

    Mandy- Thank you bunches. Stick around, we’ll go places!

    SW- Will do!

    Valli- I’ll work on them both, then! No dog? Well, I can’t say I blame you right now. They’re lucky they have velvety ears and soulful eyes. That’s all I’m sayin’…

    Jackie- Shucks. Cut it out! (Thank you!) Grand Marnier is now on the docket!

    Ciaochowlinda- Oh, I was more than a little mad. Believe me! That small bowl of it that I did get to eat was fantastic. Sigh.

  6. Gerilynne says

    I found your blog and so glad I did! Your story reminds me of a similar incident requiring my cat Mischief, pumpkin pie and Thanksgiving. My husband’s in the Army and we always try to invite Soldiers over for Thanksgiving who otherwise would be spending the day alone in the barracks. On Thanksgiving Eve, I baked a pumpkin pie. It was the last thing I did before going to bed and set it on the counter to cool. The next morning, as I moved the pie, I noticed the tiniest little nibble missing from it (way too small to have been a human nibble!). Thank God for whipped cream!
    PS: I second the request for the marscapone cheese recipe!

  7. says

    Sign me up for the mascarpone and Grand Marnier lessons. Sorry about your tiramisu. I think I would cry if that happened to me. The travesty.

  8. Christine says

    I look forward to both “extra” recipes so we can all get about making this one! Thanks! (I note Evil Genius seems to be getting off free and clear on this one…)

  9. Theresa says

    As the owner of a coonhound, I can relate (unfortunately). I swear, Prudence is like a goldfish, she’ll eat until she bursts! Please post the recipes for the mascarpone and Grand Marnier! As usual, your blog is great, love the pics and the stories behind them!

  10. Jonathan says

    Oh don’t tease us like that, this month is make your own cheese month is our house. Who doesn’t want 2 lbs of mascarpone?

  11. Nina says

    Me, me, me, me, me….pleaseee post the recipes for Grand Marnier, Marscarpone, Ladyfingers, and whatever else you know to do homemade… you can keep the dog! :o) teehee

  12. Nina says

    Oh, and I cannot believe you managed to turn the most delicious dessert in the world into something healthy with all those antioxydants from the blueberries…way to go!

    • Rebecca says

      Gerilynn- Hambone did not take such a little bite. Considering that his face is about the size of the bowl, I’m surprised he didn’t eat the bowl, too.

      Jennifer- Thank you! Duly noted.

      Jenny B.- Oh, I came close!

      Karen- Yes, ma’am. Mascarpone post coming up late today or early tomorrow!

      Christine- He is getting off scott-free. He was devastated. And the trifle dish has a great lid with a tight seal. I would’ve thought it would be safe, too. (Besides, he just bought me a pressure canner :-) )

      Theresa- Shameless, aren’t they? Absolutely ZERO self-regulating with food. They’re kind of like me. :-) Thank you!

      Jonathon- Comin’ at ya. And that’s my question, too.

      Nina- Super healthy, right? :-) I’m on it!

  13. NLDavison says

    This recipe looks fantastic. I cannot wait for you to post the recipes for the mascarpone or Grand Marnier. Thanks for the post and I will have to read your blog more often!

  14. Stephanie says

    Congrats on being featured by Pioneer Woman! I am so anxious to make this. I can’t eat chocolate and love blueberries so this should help me be in Heaven on Earth! Thank you! Am also looking forward to learning how to make homemade Grand Marnier (have already read your homemade mascarpone another one I’m looking forward to trying!).

  15. Debbie says

    If you go to my blog, Our country Home, you can read about a similar incident that happened a few days ago in my house. I’ve never hated a dog so much in my life!

  16. Amber C says

    I stumbled upon this recipe while searching for “blueberry.” I had just eaten some wonderful blueberries and wanted to make something really nice. I just finished assembling this and placing it in the fridge. I do have one question. You called for both the egg whites and the yolks. I remember that you aren’t supposed to eat raw cookie dough because of raw egg, how does this work in relation to the marscapone cream? I cannot wait to try it, it looks delicious. Thank you so much for the wonderful step-by-step instructions.

  17. Ali says

    Just found your site….LOVE IT!
    Had to comment even though its late in the game. My Mom has an “underfed” Hambone too! Haha! Too funny. He definitely is a counter surfer, but he doesn’t get this good stuff!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>